Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

2 discussions · 2 posts

Samantha Kenyetta-Evon Cothran, 23, was shot and killed in Buffalo, New York, on May 13, 2012.

MC MC

Samantha Kenyetta-Evon Cothran, 23, was shot and killed in Buffalo, New York, on May 13, 2012. She and her sister were leaving a house party on Minnesota Avenue just hours after a Mother’s Day celebration when gunfire erupted and Samantha was struck. She had recently celebrated her birthday and was about to start a job as a pharmacist.

The party drew roughly 100 to 150 people, yet investigators say witness cooperation has been minimal. Authorities — including the Buffalo Police Department and the FBI — have investigated a theory that the shooting was retaliatory and tied to local gang violence, with an assailant firing into the crowd. In 2019 someone who attended the party claimed to know the shooter’s identity, but that tip did not produce arrests.

Anyone who was at the party or who has information that could help bring Samantha’s family justice is asked to come forward.

18 Reply Report

Samantha Cothran was 23 when she was shot and killed while leaving a crowded birthday party on Minnesota…

MC MC

Samantha Cothran was 23 when she was shot and killed while leaving a crowded birthday party on Minnesota Avenue in Buffalo, New York, on the night of May 13, 2012. She had graduated from Nardin and Fisk University with a bachelor’s degree in chemistry and was pursuing a career as a pharmacist. Another partygoer was wounded and survived the shooting.

Despite numerous people at the gathering, the shooter was not immediately identified and the investigation went cold. The Buffalo Police Department lists the homicide as an active, open case; no arrests or publicly named suspects have been announced. Samantha’s mother and sisters have made public appeals for information and remember her as a beloved daughter, aunt, and sister.

If anyone was at that party or has information about the shooting on Minnesota Avenue that night, please come forward to assist the ongoing investigation.

18 Reply Report