Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for Joseph Van McGhee:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

I recently went down a rabbit hole about the Joseph Van McGhee case and can't stop thinking about how incredibly unfair it was for him, someone already suffering from a life-altering injury only to lose his life in such a senseless way. My heart goes out deeply to his family and friends who had to endure this trauma. I stumbled upon some old articles discussing how the violence in Birmingham was so rampant during that period, with so many cases just like Joseph's being part of that grim statistic. It's gut-wrenching to think about the impact on the community back then. Seeing how fragile life can be in these situations really puts things into perspective. How did the city or local organizations respond to this surge in violence during 2007? I hope there was some kind of support network available for families affected by these tragedies.
This case has always deeply saddened me, especially thinking about the circumstances surrounding Joseph Van McGhee’s death. Being in a wheelchair must have already been incredibly tough for him, and then to be caught in such a tragic situation is just devastating. It's alarming how someone could use another person, especially someone so vulnerable, as a human shield. It really makes you question humanity at times.
I’ve read that the justice system can be complicated, but the outcome of Davarrios Noel's trial leaves me puzzled. How could someone be found not guilty when they used a person as a shield during an altercation that ended in death? I can't imagine how Joseph's family must feel going through the trial and verdict process.
Also, why wasn’t Edderick Anderson charged when he fired the fatal shot, even if he was injured himself? It seems like there are a lot of layers to this incident, and I wonder if all angles were thoroughly explored. It’s frustrating and sad to think about how often justice might not be served, and how many families have to live without closure. My heart goes out to all who are impacted by this tragedy. Anyone have thoughts on why this charge didn't stick or have insights from similar cases?
Does anyone else feel like the justice system really failed Joseph Van McGhee? I can't imagine what his family must be going through, knowing that both the person who used him as a shield and the one who fired the fatal bullet weren't held accountable for his death. It just doesn’t seem right that Noel was found not guilty and Anderson wasn't charged at all. Living in Birmingham at that time must have been terrifying with all those homicides, but when something like this happens, it makes you question how safe anyone really is if justice isn't served for victims like Joseph. My heart goes out to his family, who deserved so much more than this outcome.