- Home
- Cases
- Get Involved
- Community
- Tools
- Info
-
Account
- NOT A MEMBER
Become a Member! - LOGIN
- NOT A MEMBER
- Search Cases

Clifford
BOYLE
101
47
68 inches
68 inches
214 lbs
214 lbs
White / Caucasian
Male
In the early hours of a cold St. Patrick's Day in 1995, a group of six teenage friends, including 17-year-old Jay Boyle, vanished from Pickering, Ontario. After attending a party, the group of boys made their way to the local marina. The youths were Jay Boyle, Chad Smith, 18, Robert Rumboldt, 17, Danny Higgins, 16, Michael Cummins, 17, and Jamie Lefebvre, 17. What began as a night of youthful celebration turned into an enduring mystery, leaving their families and community searching for answers for decades. The last time the boys were thought to have been seen was in the vicinity of Frenchman's Bay at the marina. The prevailing theory put forth by the Durham Regional Police was that the six boys stole a 14-foot Boston Whaler-type boat and possibly a water tricycle for a joyride on the dangerously cold waters of Lake Ontario. It is believed that they encountered trouble on the lake, which led to their boat capsizing, and that the boys ultimately succumbed to the frigid temperatures. Despite extensive searches, no trace of the boys or the boat was ever recovered from the lake, a fact that has long troubled those involved in the case. The only piece of potential evidence that ever surfaced was a gas can, believed to be from the boat, which washed ashore in Wilson, New York. The lack of physical evidence has made it difficult for authorities and families to definitively conclude what happened that night. Over the years, the case of the "Lost Boys of Pickering" has remained unsolved, marked by questions and a painful absence of closure for the families. Some have criticized the initial police response, suggesting that crucial time may have been lost in the early stages of the investigation. There have been reported sightings of some of the boys in the days following their disappearance, though these leads did not resolve the case. A significant moment of hope came in 1998 when human remains wearing red jeans were found in the Niagara River; Jay Boyle had been wearing red jeans the night he disappeared. However, DNA testing eventually confirmed the remains did not belong to Jay. The enduring mystery has left a profound impact on the community, with the families left to grapple with the unknown fate of their sons. The case is an overview of a group of teenagers who disappeared without a trace, leaving behind only a theory of a tragic accident on the lake, a theory that the complete lack of evidence has never allowed to be fully accepted as fact.
Pants Black, Dark trousers Shirt Blue, with white dots Amputation Right Index Finger, End of finger missing
Jul 24, 1972
Flower Pot Island
Ontario
Bruce Peninsula OPP OPP ONCMPUR ; 1-705-330-4144;
Ontario
1-877-934-6363
1-877-934-6363
Law Enforcement
RM06041631
Bruce Peninsula OPP OPP ONCMPUR ; 1-705-330-4144;
Brown
Blue
Blue
Build: Heavy; Hair details: Short
No
Read full forum posts and contribute to this case discussion.
Unlock forum access — $3.97/month