Account
Jan 27, 2026
Jan 27, 2026
Matthew
Penn
62
62
5'10 inches
185 lbs
White
Male
The disappearance of Matthew Penn is a story marked by conflicting details and a frustrating lack of answers. In the spring of 2020, the 62-year-old man vanished, leaving behind a life in the Chicago area. There are two different accounts of his last known whereabouts. One report states that Matthew was last seen on March 7, 2020, in the vicinity of the 2200 block of West Rosemont Avenue in Chicago. Another version of events places his last confirmed sighting on May 3, 2020, at a Mariano's grocery store on West Touhy Avenue in the suburb of Skokie, Illinois. This discrepancy in dates and locations has created a challenge for those trying to piece together the timeline of his disappearance. Matthew, also known as Matt, was a white male with brown hair and hazel eyes. He stood five feet, ten inches tall, and weighed around 185 to 195 pounds. A notable identifying feature is a large tattoo of a compass located on his back between his shoulder blades. When he was last seen, it is believed Matthew was wearing a grey sweater, blue jeans, and a leather jacket that was either black or brown. He was thought to be driving his black 2009 Nissan Altima, which had a distinct red interior and an Illinois license plate of HBJ59. The vehicle became a key point of interest in the search for him. Several months after he was reported missing, his car was located. It was found parked in the Rogers Park neighborhood of Chicago, specifically in the 7000 block of North Ridge Boulevard, a location not far from his apartment. The discovery of the car, however, did not provide the breakthrough that was hoped for. The Chicago Police Department conducted a thorough inspection of the Nissan Altima, but the search yielded no signs of criminal activity or any indication of foul play. The Chicago Police Department has been investigating the case, but the investigation has been hampered by a lack of significant leads. There has been no activity on his financial accounts, and he has not made contact with any family or friends since he was last seen. The public has been asked to provide any information they might have, but the passage of time has only deepened the mystery surrounding his case. The case remains an active and unresolved missing person investigation. The overview of this case is one of quiet disappearance and lingering uncertainty. With conflicting dates for his last sighting and the discovery of his car yielding no clues, the circumstances surrounding what happened to Matthew Penn are still unknown. The lack of evidence and leads has left a void of information, making his disappearance a perplexing and sorrowful mystery for his community and investigators.
Mar 07, 2020
Chicago
Illinois
Chicago
Chicago Police Departmen
312-744-8266
05/25/2026
