206 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.
Case Description
Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Cynthia Robin Gooding, aged 16, was last seen on September 3, 1974, in Marathon, Florida. She and her friend, 12-year-old Teresa Alfonso, were dropped off at the Marathon Movie Theater by Alfonso's mother. The girls never made it into the theater, and they were later reported to have been seen leaving in a white or yellow van, allegedly headed to a party. This was the first time Cynthia and Teresa had gone out unsupervised, and neither has been seen since.

Cynthia was a high school juni ...Read More
Last Seen: Sep 03, 1974
Victim Details

Apr 15, 2010

Feb 07, 2023

Cynthia

Gooding

66

16

58 inches

62 inches

87 lbs

100 lbs

White / Caucasian

Female

Sep 03, 1974

Marathon

Florida

Monroe County

33050

86

26594

Monroe County Sheriff's Office - Major Crimes Unit

MARATHON

Florida

Monroe County

33050

Vince Weiner

Detective

3103 OVERSEAS HWY, Florida

3052892410

County

Law Enforcement

M743432; 74-203432

Monroe County Sheriff's Office - Major Crimes Unit

Brown

Green

Green

11/25/2025


Area Last Seen: