Wilson Jay Mickler, a 22‑year‑old white male with brown hair, brown eyes, and standing approximately 5′7″ to 5′8″ and weighing between 120 and 130 lbs, disappeared from St. Augustine in 1979. His distinguishing features included a six‑ to seven‑inch scar on the inside of his right thigh, a scar in the center of his chest where his spleen was removed, and a one‑inch scar on the left side of his face.
# Disappearance details
According to *The Charley Project*, Mickler was last seen at about **9:00 p.m. on October 27, 1979**, at the Green Door bar on State Road 16 in St. Augustine, from which he never returned home. He reportedly called his wife from the bar that evening; when he failed to arrive home later that night, she alerted authorities. Local witnesses, including a man named Wayne Sutton, confirmed seeing Mickler at the bar that night and suggested a fight might have occurred, fueling the belief that foul play may have been involved.
Some sources elsewhere mention a last seen date of **March 1, 1979**, with case number MP11206 tied to St. Augustine and matching personal descriptors. However, authoritative sources focused on his disappearance—including *The Charley Project*, *NamUs*, and *The Disappeared Blog*—consistently assert the October 27 date; thus, that date is regarded as more reliable.
# Investigation and leads
Following his disappearance, investigators received various leads. In **1982**, purported sightings of Mickler working aboard shrimp boats in Florida, Georgia, and even North Carolina emerged, but none were substantiated. In **2009**, a woman reported that a man identifying himself as Daniel Wilson—who turned out to be Mickler’s brother‑in‑law—claimed to have killed Mickler and dumped his body near the Green Door. When interviewed in Georgia, Wilson admitted the statement was a “jest,” saying it stemmed from a contentious relationship and that Mickler had treated his sister roughly; police considered the claim not credible and no charges were filed.
No person has ever been formally named as a suspect. Wayne Sutton and Daniel Wilson have been questioned, but neither has been publicly identified by law enforcement as a suspect.
# Current status
Although several case details and physical descriptions carry case file number **MP11206**, Mickler’s disappearance remains unsolved and is officially classified as a presumed foul‑play case. His status is still listed as “endangered missing.” His date of birth is November 29, 1956, making him 22 when he disappeared and roughly 68 years old today if still alive.
# Appeals and public awareness
Publicly accessible information on Mickler’s case largely comes from missing‑persons databases and cold‑case resources like *The Charley Project* and blogs specializing in unsolved disappearances. Law enforcement agencies such as the St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office have encouraged anyone with information about his disappearance to come forward, but no credible new leads have surfaced in recent years.
In summary, Wilson Jay Mickler disappeared from St. Augustine, Florida, late on **October 27, 1979**, after leaving a bar called the Green Door. Despite some unverified early leads and a mistaken 2009 claim by a relative, his case remains unresolved. Foul play is strongly suspected, but no individual has ever been charged, and his whereabouts or fate remain unknown.Last Seen: Mar 1, 1979
