John Fitzgerald Missing Person Case

On August 23, 2013, a day that should have been marked by celebration, 51-year-old John W. Fitzgerald, Jr. of Needham, Massachusetts, disappeared in the waters off of Nantucket. He was aboard a private recreational fishing vessel when he is believed to have fallen overboard. The incident occurred on the eve of his 52nd birthday, turning a time of anticipated joy into one of profound loss and uncertainty for his loved ones. Accounts suggest Fitzgerald was alone at the back of the boat just before he went missing. It remains uncertain whether he was wearing a life jacket at the time.

Following his disappearance, an extensive search and rescue operation was launched. The United States Coast Guard, alongside the Nantucket Harbor Master, scoured the waters in a determined effort to find him. Despite their thorough efforts, which are noted to have gone above and beyond standard search and rescue protocols to maximize the chances of finding him, the search was ultimately suspended after about 24 hours. The Coast Guard expressed its condolences to the family, acknowledging the grim reality that despite their best efforts, some searches do not end with a successful rescue.

In the absence of his recovery, John Fitzgerald was presumed to have been lost at sea. His body has never been found, leaving a painful void for his family and friends. An obituary published in the Boston Globe remembered him as a lifelong Needham resident who was enormously well-liked, known for his quick wit and wry sense of humor. The overview of this case is one of a sudden and tragic accident. A man enjoying a day on the water vanished without a trace, leading to a significant but unsuccessful search effort and leaving a community to mourn a beloved individual who was lost to the unforgiving sea.
Last Seen: Aug 23, 2013

Missing Person / NamUs #MP22132

JOHN FITZGERALD Obituary (1961 - Needham, MA - Boston Globe

Man missing after falling off boat on his birthday near Chatham

Missing Murdered (Un)Identified in New England | iHeart

August 2013 - Missing Murdered (Un)Identified in New England ...

Needham Man Goes Missing on Birthday off Chatham - Patch

John Fitzgerald Obituary - Shrewsbury, MA

John Fitzgerald Dubose | State of California - Department of Justice