Crime Solvers Central
CSC
251 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Kimberly Toboz, a 38-year-old woman from Warren, Ohio, was last seen on January 21, 2015, leaving her home on Leavitt Road. She was reportedly wearing pajamas and slippers at the time and left to go to a convenience store. Kimberly was driving a Honda CRV, which was later found abandoned in February behind a strip mall in Mahoning County, with no clues or signs of foul play inside. Despite multiple investigations and searches, the circumstances surrounding her disappearance remain unclear.
...Read More
Last Seen: Jan 21, 2015

Victim Details

Jun 30, 2015

Jan 05, 2024

Kimberly

Toboz

48

38

68 inches

243 lbs

White / Caucasian

Female

Kimberly Dawn Toboz, a 38-year-old mother from Warren, Ohio, vanished under perplexing circumstances. On the morning of January 21, 2015, she was last seen leaving her residence on North Leavitt Road in Leavittsburg. She was reportedly driving to a convenience store at the time of her disappearance. Family members noted that she left home wearing pajamas and slippers, an detail that adds to the unsettling nature of her case. Compounding the mystery, Kimberly had a job interview scheduled for later that day, an appointment for which she was reportedly very excited. Her clothes for the interview were laid out, along with her jewelry and makeup, suggesting she had every intention of returning home. The investigation into Kimberly's disappearance took a significant turn when her vehicle, a 2009 silver Honda CRV, was discovered abandoned in neighboring Mahoning County. The car was found in February behind a small strip mall in Boardman. According to the Warren Township police chief, the vehicle appeared to have been recently cleaned, and a search of the car yielded no immediate clues or anything suspicious. The lack of evidence within the vehicle deepened the mystery surrounding what had happened to Kimberly after she was last seen. Her daughter poignantly continued to pay her mother's cell phone bill for months, hoping for any sign of contact, but the calls went straight to voicemail until the number was eventually reassigned. Years have passed since Kimberly Toboz was last seen, and her case remains an active investigation with many unanswered questions. Despite the efforts of the Warren Township Police Department and appeals from her family for any information, her whereabouts are still unknown. Her daughter has expressed fears that her mother may have met with foul play, possibly related to struggles with drugs, or that she may have overdosed and her body was disposed of. However, she also emphasized that her mother had always stayed in touch in the past, even when facing personal challenges. The case is a heart-wrenching puzzle, marked by the strange circumstances of her departure, the clean state of her recovered vehicle, and the silence that has followed. The overview of the case reflects a family left in limbo, holding onto hope while grappling with the painful possibilities of what might have happened to Kimberly.

Jan 21, 2015

Warren

Ohio

Trumbull County

44483

31606

Warren Township PD

Leavittsburg

Ohio

,

15-0004989

2015-01-22

Warren Township PD

Brown

Brown

Brown

05/26/2026


Area Last Seen: