Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 4 sources
Frank Fraser was a respected and brave veteran of the Saint Paul Police Department in Minnesota, where he had served for two decades. The 47-year-old White male detective had built a reputation for his resolve and dedication to law enforcement. His commitment to protecting the city would ultimately place him in the path of a desperate fugitive in the summer of 1911. He was a family man, survived by his wife, daughter, and mother.

The series of events that led to the fatal encounter began with a warning sent to police departments and milliners across the Midwest. A thief named John Lewis was suspected of stealing $1,000 worth of fine ostrich plumes from a wholesaler in Indianapolis. On the late afternoon of Saturday, August 12, 1911, Samuel Weiss, the owner of S. Weiss & Co. millinery store at 234 East Fourth Street in downtown Saint Paul, spotted a man matching the thief's description loitering in his shop. Suspecting the man was planning a robbery, Weiss telephoned the Central police station. Detective Frank Fraser, working in plainclothes, was dispatched to investigate.

Fraser arrived and began surveillance. When the store closed at 5:00 p.m., the suspect left, and Fraser followed him to Fourth and Wacouta Streets. There, the man boarded a westbound Selby-Lake streetcar. Fraser followed him aboard, likely planning a quiet arrest near the police station, which was just eight blocks away. The detective was unaware of the suspect's true identity: he was not merely a plume thief named John Lewis, but Peter Juhl, a 29-year-old armed convict who had recently escaped from the Stillwater Penitentiary. Juhl had served only five months of a nine-year sentence for robbing a Minneapolis jewelry store.

As the streetcar neared the intersection of Third and Market Streets, close to the police station, Detective Fraser made his move. He approached Juhl from behind, placed his hands on his shoulders, and announced he was under arrest. Juhl reacted instantly, wheeling around and drawing a revolver from his hip pocket. He fired at Fraser, the bullet striking the detective in the abdomen and piercing several internal organs. Despite the severe wound, Fraser grappled with Juhl, trying to wrest the gun away as he called for help. The gunshot sent the other passengers into a panic; many scrambled to escape the car through windows and doors.

The commotion attracted the attention of St. Paul Police Patrolman Michael Fallon, who was on his beat at Fourth and St. Peter Streets. Hearing the shot, he ran half a block and boarded the now-stopped streetcar. Fallon used his club to strike Juhl on the head multiple times, knocking him unconscious and ending the violent struggle. While Patrolman Fallon dragged the subdued suspect to the Central police station, an ambulance rushed Detective Fraser to St. Joseph’s Hospital.

At the police station, records from Stillwater prison confirmed the suspect's identity as Peter Juhl and revealed his extensive criminal history. In the hospital, doctors fought to save Detective Fraser's life, but his injuries were too severe. After clinging to life for two days, Frank Fraser died on Monday, August 14, 1911. Peter Juhl later pleaded guilty to first-degree murder and was sentenced to life in prison, returning to the same penitentiary from which he had escaped. Years later, he was transferred to the St. Peter State Hospital's ward for the "tubercular insane," where he died on August 10, 1930.