Christine Cole, a 10-year-old girl from Pawtucket, Rhode Island, was remembered by her family as a child who knew her neighborhood well. As the oldest child of a young single mother, Margie, it was not unusual for Christine to help by running errands. Just two days after her tenth birthday, on the cold evening of January 6, 1988, her mother sent her on a short walk to a local market to buy milk and clams for supper. Christine asked if she could also get some penny candy as a birthday treat, and her mother agreed. It was a trip she had made before, but this time, she would never come home.
Around 5:15 p.m., Christine left her family's apartment on West Avenue. When she hadn't returned by 6:30 p.m., her mother's boyfriend, Oscar Waldron, went to look for her. A clerk at Saint's Market on Slater Street confirmed Christine had been there and left only 15 minutes before Waldron arrived. Investigators later pieced together some of her movements.
She first went to Red's Seafood on Mineral Spring Avenue just before 6 p.m., where she bought clams and chips. She was next seen at a friend's apartment, but without the bag from the seafood store. After playing with dolls for about an hour, she left, declining a ride home. The last confirmed sighting was around 7 p.m. at Saint's Market, where she bought a gallon of milk. The store owner recalled her hands were cold and gave her a single mitten that had been left behind. An unconfirmed report placed her at another market with a second girl later that night, between 9:30 and 10 p.m. Her mother, Margie, reported her missing to Pawtucket Police at 8:45 p.m.
The search for Christine ended in heartbreak 54 days later. On February 28, 1988, her body washed ashore on Conimicut Point Beach in Warwick, about 15 miles from where she was last seen. The medical examiner determined her cause of death was drowning, but the manner of death was ruled undetermined. The autopsy revealed bruises on her arms and thigh, but no signs of trauma or sexual assault. Due to the mysterious circumstances, police immediately began treating Christine's death as a homicide.
For more than 30 years, the case grew cold. It was one of several unsolved Rhode Island cases featured on a deck of cold case playing cards created by the Pawtucket Police Department in 2018; Christine's face was on the Queen of Hearts. In August 2018, Detective Susan Cormier of the Pawtucket Police Department’s new cold case unit reopened the investigation. She discovered that evidence from the case had been submitted for forensic testing in 2008, but the results, returned in 2010, were never added to the case file. Those results showed a small reddish-brown stain on the inside of Christine's pants. Further testing with modern technology produced a partial male DNA profile.
This DNA profile led investigators to a man who had not been born when Christine disappeared. Police then focused on his father, Joao Monteiro, who was 59 years old in 2019. A background check revealed Monteiro had lived in an apartment directly above Saint's Market, where Christine was last seen. After obtaining a DNA sample from Monteiro, police announced a match to the evidence on Christine's pants. In July 2019, Monteiro was arrested and charged with her murder. He denied ever knowing Christine or having any involvement in her death.
Six months later, in early 2020, the Rhode Island Attorney General's Office dropped all charges against Monteiro. Prosecutors stated the DNA evidence was insufficient for trial, as it could not exclude other male relatives of Monteiro. The investigation into his arrest later revealed that while an initial test of the stain on Christine's pants was presumptively positive for blood, a second, more conclusive test was negative. Furthermore, FBI lab reports from 1988 and 1998 had found no blood or semen on the pants.
In January 2021, Joao Monteiro filed a federal civil lawsuit against the Pawtucket Police Department and others involved in his arrest, claiming they had fabricated evidence to solve the high-profile case. Monteiro, a Cape Verdean immigrant, alleged he lost his job and apartment and that his life was destroyed by the wrongful accusation. In November 2024, just before the case was set to go to trial, the city of Pawtucket's insurer agreed to a $1 million settlement with Monteiro. While the city admitted no wrongdoing, one of Monteiro's attorneys stated that the significant settlement suggested they knew something was wrong.
As of November 2024, a spokeswoman for the city of Pawtucket confirmed that Christine Cole's death remains an open and unsolved homicide investigation. Anyone with information about the case is asked to call the Rhode Island Cold Case Hotline at 1-877-RI-SOLVE.