Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 5 sources
Shirley Reine was a 51-year-old woman deeply enmeshed in the complex and often dangerous world of her husband, a notorious Falmouth, Massachusetts, figure. When she was 19, she fell in love with Melvin Reine Sr., a man known locally as the "Falmouth Fox" for his cunning. Melvin was a convicted arsonist suspected in a string of other serious crimes, including the 1971 disappearance of his first wife, Wanda Medeiros. Shirley and Melvin lived together for decades before marrying in 1999, and she became a stepmother to his two sons, Melvin Jr. and Todd, whom she had once babysat. Despite the family's dark reputation, Shirley's sister, Loretta Gilfoy, remembers her by the life they shared together.

On the morning of May 10, 2005, a contractor named Michael Domingues arrived at Shirley's home at 657 East Falmouth Highway with two cups of coffee, one for himself and one for her. When she didn't answer the door, he looked through a glass panel on the garage and made a horrifying discovery. Shirley was on the floor, slumped halfway out of her Nissan Maxima in a pool of blood. Police determined she had been dead for about eight hours. She had been shot twice in what investigators described as a planned and targeted execution. The first shot was to her chest, and it's believed that as she fell from her car, the killer stepped closer and fired a second, fatal shot to her head. The scene was clean; the shooter left no fingerprints, no shell casings, and no murder weapon.

The investigation, led by Massachusetts State Police, immediately faced a complex web of potential suspects and motives. Shirley had been married to a man with many enemies, and she had made some of her own. At the time of her death, she was in the midst of a bitter legal battle with her stepsons, Todd and Melvin Jr. Their father had been institutionalized in 2001, and his will gave everything to Shirley. The sons contested the will, claiming their father was not mentally competent, and the case was scheduled to go to trial just nine days after Shirley was killed. Shirley had told friends, her hairdresser, and her attorney that she feared the brothers.

Hours after the murder, Todd and Melvin Jr. hired a defense attorney and declined to be interviewed by police. Three days later, Todd Reine was found in the garage with a private investigator, taking photos and measurements and using another Nissan Maxima to recreate the crime scene, arousing the suspicions of both a family friend and the police. During the subsequent investigation, both Todd and Melvin Jr. would plead the Fifth Amendment against self-incrimination when called to testify.

Years passed without an arrest. Then, in 2014, authorities indicted John Rams Jr., a man with a lengthy criminal record, for Shirley's murder. Rams had previously been convicted in 2007 for a 2002 burglary of Shirley's home, a crime he testified he committed as a favor to Todd Reine. The prosecution argued that this was an intentional killing, but the case against Rams was largely circumstantial. His defense attorney highlighted the lack of forensic evidence connecting him to the scene. After a two-and-a-half-week trial, a Barnstable Superior Court jury swiftly acquitted Rams.

The acquittal of John Rams Jr. left the case unsolved and returned suspicion to the family conflict. After Shirley's death, her stepsons gained control of the family properties and the trash-hauling business, Five Star Enterprises. Todd Reine and his girlfriend eventually moved into the house where Shirley was murdered. The cloud of suspicion over the Reine family was not new to Falmouth; it extended back decades to the disappearance of Wanda Medeiros and other violent crimes linked to Melvin Reine Sr., who died in 2013.

As of December 2024, the murder of Shirley Reine remains an open and unsolved case. Her killer has never been brought to justice, leaving her loved ones without closure. The case is a stark reminder of the long shadow of violence that surrounded the Reine family, a legacy of crime and unanswered questions that continues to haunt the Cape Cod town.