Anita Anderson, 60, was a woman devoted to her family and a partner in business to her husband of over four decades. She and Graig "Andy" Anderson, 62, had built a busy and fulfilling life together. The couple, who married in their shared hometown of Columbus, Ohio, on October 10, 1953, had lived in Puyallup, Washington, for 22 years. Anita was the vice president of finance for a mobile home park they owned and operated in Texas, and she also handled the bookkeeping for their real estate business, Pacific Realty, in nearby Tacoma. Despite their success, they had no plans to retire. They cherished their work and the life they had created, which allowed them to split their time between the temperate Washington summers and warmer Texas winters.
Most importantly, their life in Washington kept them close to their four adult children—three daughters and a son—and their seven beloved grandchildren.
The couple was deeply involved in their grandchildren's lives, and it was a school concert for one of them that marked the last time they were seen alive. On the evening of Tuesday, May 16, 1995, Andy and Anita attended the event at Cascade Christian School in downtown Puyallup. They were seen leaving around 8:30 p.m., presumably to head back to their comfortable two-story home in an upscale South Hill neighborhood. The following day, May 17th, was filled with an unnerving silence. Calls to the Anderson home went unanswered. Concerned, their daughter and son-in-law went to check on them that evening.
At 8:40 p.m., they made a devastating discovery inside the residence in the 3700 block of 21st Street SE. Andy and Anita were found together on their living room couch, both having been shot multiple times in the head. Puyallup Police were called to the scene and immediately began a double homicide investigation under case number 95003389. The scene was perplexing to investigators. There were no signs of a struggle or forced entry, and it did not appear that anything had been stolen from the home. The nature of the crime, described by some as "execution-style," suggested a targeted attack rather than a random burglary gone wrong.
Detectives from the Puyallup Police Department faced a case with few immediate leads. Neighbors had not seen or heard anything unusual, not even the gunshots that ended the couple's lives. Investigators theorized that the killer or killers may have entered the home on the night of May 16th and possibly laid in wait for the Andersons to return from the concert. The lack of forced entry raised the possibility that the victims knew their assailant and let them in, or that the perpetrator was somehow able to gain access without leaving a trace. Police appealed to the public for information about any suspicious people or vehicles seen near the Anderson residence on or around the day of the murders.
Andy was a decorated veteran, a retired U.S. Air Force Lieutenant Colonel who had served as an F-4 combat fighter pilot during the Vietnam War. After his military career, he earned a bachelor's degree and an MBA from the University of Washington and became a successful real estate broker. He was active in several civic organizations. Anita, while busy with their businesses, was remembered as always finding time to devote to her children and grandchildren. A joint funeral service for the couple was held on May 23, 1995, at the Puyallup Church of the Nazarene.
Decades have passed, but the brutal and mysterious murders of Andy and Anita Anderson remain a painful open wound for their family and the Puyallup community. The case has been featured on cold case lists, and investigators have periodically reviewed the evidence, hoping for a breakthrough. As of May 2025, news reports confirmed that the double homicide is still an active and unsolved investigation with the Puyallup Police Department's Criminal Investigations Division. Detectives continue to seek the one crucial tip that could finally bring justice to a loving couple whose lives were inexplicably cut short in the perceived safety of their own home. Anyone with knowledge of this case is encouraged to contact the Puyallup Police Department.