Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 7 sources
On Memorial Day, May 28, 2012, a parent's visit to a home in Puyallup, Washington, led to a horrifying discovery that would launch a years-long double-homicide investigation. After being unable to make contact, the parent peered through a window of the residence in the 9400 block of 175th Street Court East in the South Hill area and saw two bodies inside. The victims were identified as 36-year-old Jeffrey Poling of Spanaway, and his friend, 32-year-old Travis Dennis of Puyallup. Both men had been killed by single gunshot wounds to the head.

When Pierce County Sheriff's detectives arrived, they encountered what they described as a complicated and unusual crime scene. The house was locked from the inside, and all the window shades had been drawn, leading investigators to believe the victims likely knew their killer and had let them into the home. Inside, deputies found a large number of weapons, ammunition, and ballistic vests. A large eel was also discovered in a commercial-sized fish tank. The scene suggested the perpetrators had not been rushed and had taken their time.

The investigation, led by the Pierce County Sheriff's Department, soon revealed that key items were missing from the home. An AR-15 and an AK-47 rifle were gone, along with a computer tower. The fact that only the tower was taken, and not the rest of the computer, suggested to detectives that the killers believed it contained information they wanted. Detective Ed Troyer noted that this led them to believe "somebody knew something might have been on that computer." The methodical nature of the crime and the efforts to remove evidence led detectives to theorize that the murders were not random, but a targeted, professional hit carried out by someone who may have killed before.

In the years following the murders, Travis Dennis's mother, Melani Carchano, spoke about the changes she had seen in her son. "Two years before he was murdered, I noticed a major change in my son,” she explained, attributing it to drugs. She recalled her last conversation with him, pleading for him to talk to her about what was wrong. "He just said, 'I love you mom. Everything’s going to be okay.' But I knew when he walked out that something just didn’t feel right," she said. A few days later, he was gone. Both his family and investigators believe that people in Travis's circle may hold the key to solving the case but are too fearful to come forward.

Detectives spent two days processing the scene and have collected evidence they hope will one day lead to an arrest. They remain convinced that the killers have spoken about what they did and that someone, somewhere has the information needed to bring justice for Jeffrey Poling and Travis Dennis. Detective Brian Lund stated, “We believe the people that were around Travis or had dealings with him, somebody knows something, but is fearful.” Melani Carchano has pleaded for anyone with information to break their silence. “Please, if you know anything, no matter how big or how small it may be, please come forward,” she urged.

As of May 2025, the double homicide of Jeffrey Poling and Travis Dennis remains an unsolved cold case. The Pierce County Sheriff's Department continues to investigate, and the case is listed on the Tacoma-Pierce County Crime Stoppers unsolved homicides page. A reward of $1,000 is offered for information that leads to an arrest and charges in the case. Anyone with information is asked to call the anonymous tip line at 1-800-222-TIPS.