For two years, Melani Carchano had watched her only son change. A shadow had fallen over Travis Dennis, a young man from Puyallup, Washington, and his mother knew it was drugs. She tried to reach him, to pull him back. In their last conversation, she pleaded with him. "Travis, there’s something going on. You’ve got to talk to mom, please," she begged. He simply replied, "I love you mom. Everything’s going to be okay." But as he walked away, a sense of dread washed over her. "I knew when he walked out that something just didn’t feel right," she later recalled. A few days later, 32-year-old Travis was dead.
On the evening of Memorial Day, May 28, 2012, a family member went to check on Travis at his home in Puyallup’s South Hill neighborhood. After being unable to get in touch, the relative peered through a window of the house in the 9400 block of 175th Street Court East and made a horrifying discovery.
Inside, law enforcement would find the bodies of Travis Dennis and his friend, 36-year-old Jeffrey Poling of Spanaway. Both men had been killed with a single gunshot wound to the head.
The scene inside the home was unsettling and spoke to a calculated, methodical killer. Pierce County Sheriff’s detectives found no signs of a struggle or forced entry. The house was locked from the inside, and all the window shades were drawn, leading investigators to believe the victims had willingly let their killer or killers inside. The scene was described as "complicated" by investigators, who noted the presence of ballistic vests, ammunition, and a large commercial-sized fish tank containing an eel. Detective Brian Lund of the Pierce County Sheriff's Department stated that it appeared the killers took their time. "It doesn’t appear to us like they were in a hurry to leave," Lund said, "so it could be somebody who has done this in the past."
Investigators believe the murders were a professional hit. The careful nature of the crime scene suggested an attempt had been made to remove or destroy evidence. "It looked like evidence had been removed or an attempt had been made to destroy the evidence inside the house," Detective Lund explained. Several key items were missing from the residence, including multiple firearms—specifically an AR-15 and an AK-47 rifle—and a computer tower. The fact that only the hard drive and tower were taken, not the entire computer system, suggested to police that the perpetrators knew something specific might be on it.
The Pierce County Sheriff’s Department has been investigating the double homicide for over a decade. Detectives spent two days processing the complex crime scene and collected evidence they hope could one day lead to the killers. However, no suspects have ever been publicly identified, and no arrests have been made. Investigators believe that people in Travis's circle may hold the key to solving the case but are afraid to come forward. "We believe the people that were around Travis or had dealings with him, somebody knows something, but is fearful," Lund stated in a 2017 interview.
The families of Travis Dennis and Jeffrey Poling have been left with unanswered questions and enduring grief. Melani Carchano has made public pleas for anyone with information to break their silence. "Please, if you know anything, no matter how big or how small it may be, please come forward," she urged. The pain of losing her only son is a wound that cannot heal without justice.
As of May 2025, the murders of Travis Dennis and Jeffrey Poling remain listed as an unsolved cold case by the Pierce County Sheriff's Department and Crime Stoppers of Tacoma/Pierce County. The passage of time has not diminished the hope that a new lead will emerge. A reward of $1,000 is available through Tacoma-Pierce County Crime Stoppers for any information that leads to an arrest and charges in the case. Detectives ask anyone with information to call 1-800-222-TIPS (8477) or the sheriff's department at 253-591-5959. Tips can also be submitted anonymously through the P3 Tips App.