Kurt Eugene Van Dyke, a 66-year-old American man originally from Santa Cruz, California, was brutally murdered on February 14, 2026, in Hone Creek, a community near Cahuita and Puerto Viejo de Talamanca in Costa Rica's Limón province. Van Dyke was a well-known surfer, businessman, and longtime resident of Costa Rica who had established deep roots in the Caribbean coastal community. He owned Hotel Puerto Viejo and was widely respected for his contributions to surfing, particularly at the famous Salsa Brava break. Known locally as "King," he came from a prominent California surfing family. His father, Gene Van Dyke, helped pioneer surfing in Northern California, while his mother, Betty Van Dyke, was among the early female competitive surfers. Kurt had relocated to Costa Rica during the 1980s, building a life around the ocean, his business, and the community he had come to call home.
His death shocked friends, relatives, and members of the international surfing community.
On the morning of February 14, 2026, an emergency call brought Costa Rican authorities to a residence in Hone Creek following reports of a violent home invasion. The initial account indicated that armed intruders had entered the property where Van Dyke was with a 31-year-old woman identified as his romantic partner. According to the woman's reported account, the attackers threatened them, restrained her with plastic ties, and demanded valuables. The intruders allegedly stole personal belongings, a cellular telephone, and a white 2013 Hyundai Elantra before fleeing the property. When police and emergency personnel arrived, they discovered Van Dyke's lifeless body beneath a bed. His hands and feet had been restrained, a sheet covered his head, and he had suffered multiple stab wounds and signs of strangulation. Investigators also found a bloodstained knife at the scene. The woman survived without serious physical injuries and was initially treated as another victim of the apparent robbery.
The investigation was assigned to Costa Rica's Organismo de Investigación Judicial the country's judicial investigation agency. Detectives began examining physical evidence, interviewing witnesses, and reviewing surveillance footage from the surrounding area. Although the crime initially appeared to be a robbery that had escalated into a killing, investigators discovered circumstances that raised questions about the account they had received. Their examination of the property found no apparent signs of forced entry through the gates, doors, or windows. The Hyundai Elantra, which reportedly had been stolen during the attack, was subsequently recovered approximately 600 meters from the main entrance to central Cahuita. The vehicle showed no apparent damage or signs of forced entry, and its key remained in the ignition. Inside, investigators discovered the woman's handbag containing identification, bank cards, jewelry, and other valuables. Her cellular telephone was found concealed near one of the vehicle's front wheels. These discoveries led investigators to suspect that the reported theft of the automobile and telephone had been staged to conceal the circumstances surrounding Van Dyke's death.
As the investigation continued, authorities began developing a different explanation for the killing. According to information later disclosed from the criminal investigation, prosecutors believed the attack had been organized to obtain money from Van Dyke by forcing him to reveal banking information associated with his hotel business. Investigators identified his former romantic partner, publicly identified by the surnames Arroyo Ramírez, as a possible participant in the planning. They also identified a man with the surnames Gutiérrez Víctor as another suspected participant. Prosecutors alleged that Arroyo Ramírez used her personal relationship with Van Dyke to arrange a meeting at the residence and then alerted Gutiérrez Víctor and other alleged accomplices when Van Dyke was vulnerable. According to the investigative reconstruction, Gutiérrez Víctor and two additional men entered the property intending to obtain bank-card identification numbers and access to financial accounts. When the attackers allegedly failed to obtain the information they wanted, Van Dyke was subjected to severe physical violence.
A significant development came when the OIJ's cybercrime investigators examined electronic communications recovered during the investigation. According to details disclosed from the judicial case file, investigators identified WhatsApp messages allegedly exchanged between Arroyo Ramírez and a contact associated with Gutiérrez Víctor, who reportedly used the nickname KG. The messages included statements indicating that the suspected attackers could approach the residence, along with instructions to leave a door open. Investigators reported that between approximately 9:52 and 9:54 a.m. on the morning of the murder, messages were exchanged about Van Dyke's identity and the arrival of the other individuals. Surveillance evidence reportedly captured Van Dyke calling for help around 10 a.m. Shortly afterward, the suspected attackers were seen leaving in two vehicles. The emergency incident was reported at approximately 10:35 a.m. Prosecutors considered these communications and the surveillance evidence important elements in reconstructing the sequence of events, although the allegations remained subject to judicial examination.
Additional evidence presented in the investigation concerned alleged financial demands and threats made against Van Dyke before his death. According to information contained in the judicial file, investigators examined reports that Arroyo Ramírez had repeatedly sought money from him during the preceding months. The allegations included demands for approximately five million Costa Rican colones in November 2025 and an alleged demand for $1,500 on January 4, 2026. Investigators also documented accusations that threats had been made against people close to Van Dyke. During the fatal attack, according to the prosecution's account, the assailants demanded money and accused him of owing a substantial sum. These reported incidents formed part of the broader investigation into the potential financial motives behind the killing. The allegations concerning Arroyo Ramírez had not been established through a criminal conviction.
Forensic findings further demonstrated the severity of the attack. Costa Rican authorities reported that the medical examination established Van Dyke's cause of death as asphyxiation resulting from compression of the neck, accompanied by a fracture of the hyoid bone. His body also showed multiple sharp-force injuries and evidence of significant physical trauma. According to information released from the judicial investigation in November 2026, the forensic findings supported the conclusion that Van Dyke had been tortured before his death. Investigators believed the violence was intended to compel him to disclose banking information. The circumstances suggested that the killing involved more than an opportunistic burglary and that several individuals may have participated in the assault.
After nearly nine months of investigative work, Costa Rican authorities announced a major breakthrough. On November 12, 2026, OIJ agents conducted three coordinated raids in the Pocora and Astúa Pirié areas of the Guápiles region in Limón province. The operations resulted in the arrests of Arroyo Ramírez, 31, and Gutiérrez Víctor, 34, on suspicion of participating in Van Dyke's homicide. Investigators seized cellular telephones, a vehicle believed to have been used during the events surrounding the murder, and other potential evidence. Authorities alleged that the two suspects had participated in planning and carrying out the attack, although their precise roles remained matters for the courts to determine. Investigators also indicated that two additional men believed to have been involved in the killing had not yet been identified.
On November 15, 2026, the Talamanca Criminal Court ordered both arrested suspects held in preventive detention for six months while the investigation continued. The proceedings concerned suspected aggravated homicide, known under Costa Rican law as homicidio calificado. The criminal investigation was identified under case number 26-000171-0829-PE and involved prosecutors in Limón, including authorities responsible for organized-crime investigations. The detention order represented an important development in the case, but it was not a conviction or a determination of guilt. As of November 19, 2026, no criminal trial or conviction had been publicly reported in connection with Van Dyke's murder. Investigators were continuing to examine the evidence and pursue the identities of the other suspected participants.
The arrests brought renewed attention to Van Dyke's death and offered his family a measure of progress after months of uncertainty. His brother, Peter Van Dyke, described Kurt as a kind, generous, and easygoing person who was willing to help others. Following the arrests, Peter acknowledged that the family had questioned some aspects of the original account, particularly the fact that the woman reportedly survived the attack without serious injuries. Nevertheless, he emphasized that the family had avoided making premature accusations and expressed confidence in the Costa Rican investigators who had pursued the case. Peter said the arrests did not bring happiness because they could not restore his brother's life, but they represented meaningful progress toward justice. Van Dyke was survived by three children, and his family indicated that his eldest son intended to travel to Costa Rica for the eventual murder trial.
Kurt Van Dyke's death left a profound loss in both the California and Costa Rican surfing communities. For decades, he had been associated with the waves of the Caribbean coast, the hospitality business he operated, and the friendships he established after leaving his hometown. What initially appeared to be a deadly home invasion developed into a far more complicated homicide investigation involving allegations of financial coercion, a staged robbery, electronic communications between suspected accomplices, and an apparent attempt to obtain access to his banking accounts through violence. The November 2026 arrests marked a significant turning point, but important questions remained concerning the full extent of the alleged conspiracy and the identities of the additional participants. With two suspects in preventive detention and the aggravated homicide investigation continuing, Van Dyke's family and friends remained focused on obtaining accountability for the violent death of a respected surfer, businessman, father, and longtime member of the Puerto Viejo community.