In the predawn darkness of a summer night in Pittsfield, Massachusetts, a young woman’s life was cut short by a gunshot inside her family’s home, leaving behind a mystery that has endured for more than a century. May Fosburgh, 24, was a daughter and sister living with her prominent family, who had recently moved to a house at 287 Tyler Street. Her father, Robert L. Fosburgh Sr., ran a large construction company, Fosburgh & Sons, and had relocated the family to Pittsfield to oversee an expansion project for the Stanley Electric Co., a predecessor to General Electric. The Fosburghs were new to the community, having been in their home for only a few weeks before the tragedy unfolded.
On August 19, 1900, shortly after 1 a.m., chaos erupted in the Fosburgh residence. The family’s account, relayed to the first patrolman on the scene, was of a home invasion gone horribly wrong. They claimed that burglars had entered the house through the attic and descended to the second floor.
Robert Sr. allegedly awoke to find the intruders in his room and began to struggle with them. During the fight over a gun, a shot was fired, awakening the household. May, hearing the commotion, came to her father's bedroom door. A second shot rang out, and the bullet struck her in the chest. Her brother, Robert "Bertie" Fosburgh Jr., caught her as she fell. The burglars, the family said, then fled through a back bedroom window and vanished into the night.
The initial response was dramatic. Pittsfield Police Chief John Nicholson, alerted to the murder, rang the town’s fire alarm to summon citizens from their beds. He deputized a posse of 300 armed men, warning them that dangerous murderers were on the loose, and dispatched them to hunt for the alleged intruders. A massive manhunt swept through the town, but the search turned up no sign of the burglars. As the investigation progressed, police and a grand jury began to doubt the family’s story.
Investigators found that the physical evidence did not align with the Fosburghs' narrative. In the attic, where the burglars supposedly entered, dust and cobwebs were undisturbed. A rear window, the stated escape route, was found to be jammed and could not open wide enough for a person to pass through. The family's descriptions of the intruders were inconsistent. Suspicion soon fell upon a member of the household: May’s older brother, 28-year-old Robert Fosburgh Jr. Neighbors had reported hearing gunshots, and some members of the household later testified about a fight between Robert Jr. and his wife, Amy, that night. Investigators began to suspect the burglary was a fabrication to cover up a domestic tragedy.
Robert Fosburgh Jr. was arrested and charged in connection with his sister's death. His trial in July 1901 became a media sensation, attracting reporters from across the country. The prosecution argued that the family had concocted the burglar story, pointing to evidence like footprints made by one of Robert Sr.'s shoes that were meant to look like an intruder's. However, the case against Robert Jr. was largely circumstantial. The murder weapon was never found. Key testimony was excluded by the judge, including the medical examiner’s opinion that the fatal shot was fired at close range and that a second bullet hole indicated a shot fired from inside a room toward a window, not the other way around.
After six days of testimony, before the case could go to the jury, the judge made a stunning decision. Citing insufficient evidence, he ordered a directed verdict of acquittal. He stated that the prosecution had failed to prove that burglars were not involved, that Robert Jr. was the shooter to the exclusion of all others, and that the act was criminal. The verdict meant Robert Jr. could never be tried for the crime again. The courtroom reportedly erupted in applause, and the Fosburgh family celebrated at their hotel before promptly leaving Pittsfield, never to return.
No one else was ever charged in the death of May Fosburgh. The case, which once made national headlines, grew cold, becoming one of Berkshire County's most enduring unsolved murders. Historians and true-crime authors have revisited the mystery over the decades, dissecting the flimsy evidence and the trial that ended so abruptly. The case periodically resurfaces in local media, a haunting reminder of a violent death and unanswered questions.
As of May 2024, more than 120 years after the fatal gunshot on Tyler Street, the murder of May Fosburgh remains officially unsolved. The truth of what happened in the house that night died with the people who were there, leaving behind only speculation and the ghost of a young woman whose violent end became a permanent, dark chapter in the history of the Berkshires.