Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 5 sources
Patricia L. Evans was a 30-year-old mother of four who, despite her struggles, was a central part of her children’s lives. In the summer of 1987, she was living apart from her husband, James Evans, though he and their children occupied the second-floor apartment of a triple-decker at 118 Piedmont Street in Worcester, Massachusetts. Patricia battled heroin addiction and had recently been released from a detoxification center. Just a day before her death, her husband had bailed her out of jail on a prostitution charge. For her children, she was simply their mother, and the memories of their last morning together would become a confusing and painful puzzle they would spend their lives trying to solve.

On the morning of Saturday, August 8, 1987, Patricia’s children were watching television in their second-floor apartment when they heard noises from the supposedly empty unit above them. Jessica Evans, then a young child, later recalled hearing thumping sounds around 7 a.m. Her estranged husband, James, told police he had last seen Patricia at about 2:30 a.m. when she said she was going to get some water and sit on the porch. He said he then went to sleep, woke up later that morning for a siding job, and returned around 10 a.m. Knowing she sometimes sought solitude in the vacant third-floor apartment after drug binges, he went there to look for her. There, he made a devastating discovery.

Patricia Evans was found partially clad in the vacant flat. She had been sexually assaulted and strangled to death. An autopsy would later confirm the cause of death as a crushed neck and rape. In the immediate aftermath, police stated they had suspects but never publicly identified anyone. For years, the case languished, leaving a void of information that was filled with whispers and painful assumptions for Patricia's children.

The investigation into Patricia's murder is handled by the Worcester Police Department's Unresolved Homicide Unit. For decades, no arrests have been made, and the case has remained open. For Patricia’s four children—Amie, Jessica, James Jr., and Thomas—the lack of answers was compounded by family turmoil. After their mother’s death, they were separated, moving between relatives and state custody. They were told their mother had been "sick" and that their father, who also struggled with addiction, was a suspect in her murder. This belief shadowed them for years, shaping their fractured relationship with him.

Years later, as young adults, the siblings began to piece together the truth of their mother’s violent death by looking through old library records. They started to question the narrative they had been given. Jessica recalled that after hearing the thumping noises on the morning of the murder, they had tried to wake their father, who told them to go back to bed. This memory placed him in the apartment at the time police believed Patricia was being killed upstairs, casting doubt on the long-held suspicion against him. James Evans died four years before his children began their public search for answers, succumbing to illnesses related to AIDS. His daughter Jessica, who had maintained some contact with him, said he urged her to let her mother rest in peace, hinting that he knew things that would cause her family more pain.

The children's search for closure brought renewed attention to the case in 2006. "We never talked about it," her oldest daughter, Amie Fayyad, said at the time. "It was such a bad thing that screwed us up, and we thought we should just leave it alone." The pain of losing their mother was inseparable from the pain of losing their father. "After my mom died, I lost my dad, and I don’t know which one hurts more," Jessica said.

As of April 2024, the murder of Patricia Evans remains an active and unsolved homicide with the Worcester Police Department. The case was highlighted in May 2023 on the "Unsolved: Worcester" true-crime podcast, bringing her story to a new generation. Investigators hope that with the passage of time, someone with information will finally come forward. Anyone with information is encouraged to contact the Unresolved Homicide Unit at 508-799-8688 or send an anonymous text to 274637 with "TIPWPD" and a message.