Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 4 sources
Paulette “Barbara” Andrea, a 43-year-old nurse's aide originally from Nova Scotia, Canada, was a mother of five and a doting grandmother to four. She was a familiar and well-liked regular at Barney Google’s, a neighborhood tavern in the Green Island section of Worcester, Massachusetts. Friends remembered her as a "scrapper," a woman who could handle herself, which made the events of September 22, 1992, all the more shocking to those who knew her. Her life had seen hardship, including abuse she suffered as a child, but she had established a life for herself in Massachusetts working as a home health aide.

In the first hour of that Tuesday, just after midnight, Paulette hugged her friends goodbye and left Barney Google’s on Washington Street. She was seen leaving with her husband. Her walk home to her Lawrence Street apartment should have taken about 15 minutes. She never made it. Around 4:30 a.m., a person walking through Crompton Park discovered Paulette’s body. She was found facedown in a playground sandbox near the park's basketball courts. She had been beaten and strangled to death. Her wedding ring and a pearl necklace she had been wearing were gone.

The Worcester Police Department immediately launched a homicide investigation. Detectives questioned Paulette’s husband, who had reported her missing when she didn't return home, as well as several other patrons from the bar. Her family told reporters they did not believe she would have walked home alone, especially not through the park, leading them to suspect that her killer was someone she knew. One of her daughters later described Paulette's marriage as turbulent. Despite the investigation, no arrests have ever been made and no suspects have been officially named in her murder.

Paulette’s death marked the beginning of a terrifying period for the city of Worcester. Over the next six months, four other women were found strangled in the downtown area: Denise Comeau, Vicki Lehtinen, Sonia Blanco, and Evelyn Cruz. The string of killings of marginalized women created a climate of fear. While police have not officially linked the five homicides, the community noted the violent similarities. The cases put residents on edge and prompted calls for an end to violence against women.

In the weeks and years following the murder, Paulette’s family and community organizations held vigils in her memory at Crompton Park. They would tie yellow ribbons to the trees near where her body was found, light candles, and share fond memories. In May 1993, the Worcester Advisory Committee on the Status of Women planted a crabapple tree in University Park and dedicated it, along with a plaque, to Paulette and the four other women killed that fall and winter. In April 2023, the committee held another ceremony to rededicate the memorial, ensuring the women are not forgotten.

The investigation into Paulette Andrea’s murder remains open. The Worcester Police Department’s Unresolved Homicide Unit continues to maintain her case file, which was formally revisited by a detective in 2007, 15 years after her death. As of April 2023, her killing is one of dozens of unsolved homicides in the city. Her funeral was held at Sacred Heart Church three days after her death, and she is buried in Worcester County Memorial Park in the nearby town of Paxton.

Anyone with information regarding the murder of Paulette Andrea is encouraged to contact the Worcester Police Department’s Unresolved Homicide Unit at 508-799-8688. Anonymous tips can also be sent by texting 274637 with the message "TIPWPD" followed by the information, or submitted via the department's website.