A man is shot dead in his home Calvin "CJ" Simmons Jr. was a clever, creative, and deeply family-oriented man whose home was the center of every holiday and summer barbecue. A 37-year-old Black man, CJ was a natural entrepreneur, a trait that surfaced in childhood when he would borrow neighbors' rakes to start a small snow shoveling and lawn-cutting business with his sister and friends. As an adult, this drive led him to own rental properties. His sister, Shaquila "Pastor Shaq" Mathews, a well-known church pastor and community leader in their hometown of Hamilton, Ohio, remembered him as a funny guy with a big, beautiful smile who loved to laugh and joke. Though she was his younger sister, she always felt protective of him, especially due to his lifelong asthma. Above all, CJ was a devoted father to five children—four biological and a stepdaughter he embraced as his own.
The heart of his family's gatherings, CJ took special pride in Thanksgiving, often preparing four or five different kinds of turkey.
His generosity was well-known in the community, with his uncle, Terry Simmons, recalling that CJ often helped people with food and money. He was, by all accounts, a good guy with a good heart. His sister, who lived just two blocks away, was so close to her brother that when she heard police were at his house in the early hours of September 16, 2016, her first thought was that he was having a severe asthma attack. The sight of an officer pulling out caution tape told her it was something far more serious.
Around 3:45 a.m., two men broke into CJ's home in the 2200 block of University Boulevard. A frantic 911 call from a woman inside the house captured the terrifying moments. She told the dispatcher that the intruders came through the back door. One was dressed in all black, including a hoodie and latex gloves, and wore a silver "Scream" movie mask. The other also wore a black hoodie and black gloves. The woman reported that one of the men put a gun in her mouth and threatened her before they shot CJ.
Police and paramedics arrived to find Calvin Simmons Jr. with a gunshot wound to his abdomen. He was rushed to Fort Hamilton Hospital, but the injury was too severe. He died about an hour after the attack. The Butler County Coroner's Office later officially ruled his death a homicide. Hamilton Police investigators immediately began working the case, stating publicly that they did not believe it was a random act of violence and that CJ had been specifically targeted.
The Hamilton Police Department's investigation into the aggravated robbery and murder is ongoing. In the immediate aftermath, police Chief Craig Bucheit met with CJ's devastated family and pledged the department's full effort to find those responsible. However, years have passed without an arrest. The family has received few updates, a reality CJ's sister understands, acknowledging the heavy caseload detectives face. She remains certain her brother was targeted but is at a loss as to why. "As far as we knew, there were no disagreements, no red flags, nothing that we knew of," she said.
The sudden, violent loss left CJ's family shattered. His death occurred just as the holiday season was approaching, a time when he would have been hosting everyone. "That part was super tough for beyond the obvious," his sister recalled. Family members struggled to understand who would want to hurt a man they knew as generous and kind. His uncle Terry Simmons speculated that someone may have robbed him for drug money. His sister, who has comforted many grieving families in her role as a pastor, found herself grappling with the unbelievable reality of her own brother's murder. "It was just that reality that I won't see him again," she said, "so I just wanted somebody to tell me it wasn't real."
As of July 2021, the murder of Calvin Simmons Jr. remains unsolved. His family continues to hope that someone in the community will come forward with the information needed to bring them closure. "We know somebody knows," Shaquila Mathews said. "There are individual citizens in this community who know something, people that could help bring pieces of the puzzle." The Hamilton Police Department is asking anyone with information regarding this incident to call the Investigations Division at 513-868-5811, extension 2002.