Shari Faye Smith was a vibrant and talented 17-year-old with a bright future ahead of her. A senior at Lexington High School in South Carolina, she was known for her stunning, angelic singing voice. Shari was a member of the jazz band, chorus, and stage choir, and had been selected for the All-State Chorus. Voted "Wittiest" by her classmates for the senior superlatives, she was also deeply loved by her devoutly religious family, including her parents, Bob and Hilda, her older sister, Dawn, and her younger brother, Robert. The "Smith Sisters," as Shari and Dawn were known, often sang duets together at Lexington Baptist Church and other local congregations. Just days away from her high school graduation and a celebratory senior cruise to the Bahamas, Shari’s dreams were tragically cut short.
On the afternoon of Friday, May 31, 1985, Shari returned from a pool party at a friend's house.
At about 3:25 p.m., she pulled her blue Chevrolet Chevette into the long, 750-foot driveway of her family's home on Platt Springs Road in a rural part of Lexington County. She stopped at the mailbox at the end of the drive, leaving the car's engine running. Inside the house, her parents noticed the car had been parked for several minutes. Her father, Bob, grew concerned when she didn't come inside and looked out to see the car still sitting by the road. When he went to check, he found the car empty, the driver's side door ajar, and Shari's purse still inside. Shari, a white female, had vanished.
The disappearance launched one of the largest manhunts in South Carolina's history and marked the beginning of an agonizing ordeal for the Smith family. Soon after the abduction, they began receiving a series of taunting and cruel phone calls from an unknown man. The man, who spoke in a distorted voice, toyed with the family, initially claiming Shari was alive. The torment escalated when a letter arrived, penned in Shari's handwriting under duress. It was a two-page letter titled "Last Will & Testament," a final, heartbreaking message she was forced to write by her captor before she was killed. The killer continued his sadistic calls, eventually providing directions that led investigators to Shari's remains in neighboring Saluda County. An autopsy later determined she had been suffocated, likely within 12 hours of her abduction.
The investigation, involving local law enforcement and the FBI, focused intensely on the calls and the letter. A breakthrough came from a seemingly invisible clue. Forensic analysis of the stationery Shari had used to write her will revealed an indentation from a previous note, showing a partial phone number. By filling in the missing digits, the FBI traced the number to a couple who had recently hired a man for some work. That man was Larry Gene Bell, an electrician with a criminal record. Hairs found in Bell's apartment were microscopically similar to Shari's. Bell was arrested on June 27, 1985.
The horror did not end with Shari's case. On June 14, while still at large, Bell abducted 9-year-old Debra May Helmick from the front yard of her family's home in nearby Richland County. In one of his subsequent calls to the Smith family, Bell confessed to this second murder and told them where to find Debra May's body. During the calls, he often spoke with Shari's sister, Dawn, developing a strange fixation on her. It is believed he may have mistaken Shari for her look-alike older sister on the day of the abduction.
Larry Gene Bell's trial was marked by his bizarre and disruptive behavior in court, which prosecutors argued was an attempt to feign mental illness. The evidence against him, however, was overwhelming. He was convicted for the kidnapping and murder of Shari Smith and sentenced to death. He was also convicted for the murder of Debra May Helmick. After his appeals were exhausted, Larry Gene Bell, age 46, was executed in South Carolina's electric chair on October 4, 1996. He offered no final words. The case left an indelible scar on the community and two grieving families, a chilling story of terror that began at the end of a quiet country driveway.