Judy Ann Hunter, a 47-year-old woman from Waynesburg, PA, was tragically murdered in her home on February 14, 2022. Judy was born on July 7, 1974, and was a beloved mother to three children: Robin Renee Forsythe, Angel Shyann Nichol Duckworth, and Dustin Ray Joseph Duckworth. She was also survived by her siblings and her parents, Jesse Butler Sr. and Faye Yalo. Judy was known for her love of music, traveling, and spending time with friends.
The investigation into Judy Hunter's death revealed that she and her boyfriend, Kevin Williford, were found dead in their Waynesburg home with gunshot wounds. The suspects, Cortland James Rogers and Shawna Marie Smith, were arrested on the day of the discovery while in police custody for an unrelated crime. According to court documents, Rogers and Smith confronted Williford over missing jewelry and money for drugs, leading to the double homicide.
The Greene County District Attorney considered the death penalty for Rogers and Smith due to the severity of the crime. However, in November 2024, Cortland Rogers pleaded guilty to two counts of first-degree murder and other related charges, accepting a plea deal that removed the possibility of the death penalty. Shawna Smith is still awaiting trial and faces serious charges that could lead to a lengthy prison term if convicted.
The tragic loss of Judy Hunter has deeply affected her family and friends, who remember her as a loving and caring person. The case continues to be a significant point of focus for the local authorities as they seek justice for Judy and Kevin.
