Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 12 sources
Demontae Rhodes, a 24-year-old African American male from Rockford, Illinois, tragically lost his life on December 20, 2014. Demontae, known as "Montae," was a beloved member of his community, a boxer, and part-owner of R&R Rhodes Enterprises. He was deeply involved in his local church, Rockford First, and had a promising future ahead of him.

On the night of December 20, 2014, Demontae Rhodes was fatally shot in a brutal incident that also claimed the lives of his girlfriend, Martia Flint, and her two young sons, Tobias K. Smith and Tyrone Smith III. The quadruple homicide occurred in Martia Flint's apartment in Rockford. The perpetrator, Calvin L. Carter III, was later convicted of the murders. Carter, who was 24 years old at the time, had a brief relationship with Martia Flint after she and Demontae had temporarily broken up. When Martia ended her relationship with Carter to rekindle her romance with Demontae, Carter responded with violence.

The investigation revealed that Carter broke into Flint's apartment and executed the four victims in a calculated and cold-blooded manner. The motive behind the murders was rooted in Carter's anger and jealousy over Flint's decision to leave him and return to Demontae. The crime shocked the Rockford community and left a lasting impact on the families of the victims.

Calvin Carter was charged with 133 counts of first-degree murder and home invasion. During the trial, emotional outbursts from the victims' families highlighted the deep pain and loss they experienced. Despite attempts by Carter's defense to declare a mistrial due to these outbursts, the trial proceeded, and Carter was ultimately convicted. He was sentenced to four life terms plus 280 years in prison, ensuring he would never be free to harm anyone again.

The sentencing brought a sense of closure to the families, though it could never fully heal the wounds left by the loss of their loved ones. Demontae Rhodes' father, Calvin Rhodes, expressed that while the lengthy prison term could not bring back what was taken from them, it was the closest they could get to justice. The community mourned the loss of Demontae, Martia, Tobias, and Tyrone, remembering them for the joy and love they brought into the lives of those around them.