Matthew Lewis Beagle, an 18-year-old from Nokomis, Florida, tragically lost his life on October 2, 2017. Matthew was a recent graduate of Venice High School and was known for his vibrant personality and promising future. His unexpected death shocked the local community and left his family and friends in deep mourning.
The circumstances surrounding Matthew's death were part of a horrific incident that unfolded in his home.
On the night of October 2, 2017, a violent altercation occurred between Matthew's mother, Susan Rutigliano-Garcia, and her husband, Anthony Isgrig. Witnesses reported seeing Isgrig become enraged during an argument, which escalated quickly into a violent confrontation. Isgrig attacked Susan and then proceeded to shoot her, Matthew, and his stepsister, Joanna Beagle. Tragically, Matthew and his mother succumbed to their injuries, while Joanna survived despite sustaining significant injuries.
Following the shootings, Isgrig attempted to flee the scene but returned to the house shortly after. He then took his own life, completing what authorities classified as a double murder-suicide. The Sarasota County Sheriff's Office conducted an investigation into the incident, confirming that Isgrig was the sole perpetrator of the murders. The investigation revealed that the family had only recently moved to the neighborhood, and neighbors were shocked by the sudden and violent turn of events.
The case did not result in any further arrests or litigations, as the primary suspect, Anthony Isgrig, was deceased. The community of Nokomis was left to grapple with the aftermath of this tragic event, which highlighted the devastating impact of domestic violence. The loss of Matthew Beagle and his mother was deeply felt, and their memories were honored by those who knew and loved them.
