Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 4 sources
In the winter of 1990, the life of 43-year-old John Shelton was violently cut short in the borough of Queens, New York. On February 7th, Shelton was gunned down by a ski-masked assailant wielding an M-1 rifle outside a dry cleaners. This brazen act was not a random street crime, but a calculated execution intended to silence a key witness. Shelton was scheduled to testify against four individuals charged in a drug-related homicide that had claimed the life of his long-time girlfriend, Maxine Peterson.

The tragic story began nearly two years earlier, on May 28, 1988. Shelton was at home with Peterson when she was tragically killed in a hail of twenty bullets. Peterson was in her kitchen, holding her 6-week-old infant, when the gunfire erupted. Miraculously, the baby was unharmed. Authorities believed Peterson's murder was an act of retaliation by drug dealers, allegedly in response to a shooting carried out by her son earlier that same day.

As a witness to his girlfriend's murder, John Shelton's testimony was crucial for the prosecution. His death was a direct attempt to derail the impending trial and ensure the suspects in Peterson's killing would not face justice. The authorities identified the man responsible for Shelton's assassination as a hired killer. Following an investigation, an 18-year-old named Michael Bethea, who was already incarcerated on drug and weapon charges, was formally charged with the murder of John Shelton.