Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

2 discussions · 2 posts

Phyliss E. Brewer, 19 and known as Sparky, was last seen leaving a residence on North Hubbard Road in…

CD CD

Phyliss E. Brewer, 19 and known as Sparky, was last seen leaving a residence on North Hubbard Road in Lowellville, Ohio, on June 13, 1981, intending to go for a walk and never returned. At the time she was a Conneaut High School student living with her father in Conneaut and was described as five feet six inches tall with blonde or red hair. Her disappearance was not reported for decades and no official investigation began until 2014, when the coroner’s office handling a sister’s affairs discovered Phyliss was unaccounted for.

Investigators later obtained a DNA sample from a niece to aid searches, but the case is complicated by court records showing a Phyllis Brewer had interactions with the Conneaut Police Department in 1982, including a ten-day jail sentence in May 1982. That discrepancy has led authorities to consider that Phyliss may have vanished later than 1981 or that someone else used her identity. Some surviving relatives have suggested the possibility of the father’s involvement, but the trail is cold because both parents and all siblings are deceased.

Does anyone have memories of Phyliss, knew the family in 1981–82, or can help clarify the 1982 records?

18 Reply Report

Phyllis Brewer, known to some as Sparky, was 19 when she disappeared from Lowellville, Ohio.

WN WN

Phyllis Brewer, known to some as Sparky, was 19 when she disappeared from Lowellville, Ohio. On June 13, 1981, she reportedly left her home on North Hubbard Road for a walk and was never seen or heard from again. She was described as a white female, about 5 feet 6 inches and 130 pounds, with shoulder-length straight strawberry blonde or red hair parted in the center, long bangs and a scar on one hand. Only her bra size is recorded among clothing details.

No missing person report was filed at the time; the disappearance did not come to official attention until 2014 after her sister died, when the Mahoning County Sheriff’s Office opened an investigation. Investigators face limits: all of Phyllis’s immediate family members are deceased, tips have been few and none have produced results since 2019, and puzzling court records show a person named Phyllis Brewer had contact with Conneaut police in 1982, raising questions about timing or identity. Anyone who knew Phyllis, lived in Lowellville or Conneaut in 1981, or has information is asked to come forward.

18 Reply Report