Kristine Costantino, 40, was shot and killed inside her Middle Island, New York, apartment on Artist Lake Drive on New Year’s Eve 2023. The shooting occurred at about 11:27 a.m. during a gathering of five people. Emanuel reportedly called 911 after the shooting but fled before officers arrived.

Officers who entered the apartment found Costantino still able to repeatedly name Emanuel as her shooter. She was taken to Stony Brook University Hospital, where she was pronounced dead. If anyone attended that gathering or has information about what happened that morning, please share what you know.