Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
295 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for Benjamin Collings:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

I was recently reading about the chilling case of Benjamin Collings, and something about the investigation stood out to me. The presence of a broken milk bottle on the Penguin caught my attention. It seems like an unusual item to be involved in such a brutal crime, but could it be potential evidence pointing to the attackers? It's interesting how small details like this can sometimes unravel important clues. Perhaps the bottle was used as an improvised weapon or was involved in the struggle somehow. It's so frustrating to think about how difficult things must have been for investigators back then, without the technology we have today. My thoughts are with the Collings family—I can only imagine the pain of not having closure even all these years later. Does anyone else have any theories on the role of the milk bottle in this tragic event?
Hi everyone,
I've been digging through some old newspaper archives and came across an interesting detail regarding the state of the Penguin after Benjamin's murder. It seems like there was a peculiar set of footprints leading away from the spot where the boat was docked. From what I read, these footprints were both barefoot and in shoes, suggesting there might've been a third person involved or possibly a change after the attack. Could this mean one of the attackers returned to shore a different way, or is it possible Benjamin might have managed to untie himself at some point and attempt an escape? My heart goes out to Benjamin’s family, having to deal with such a brutal and perplexing crime. Does anyone else find this detail intriguing, or am I reading too much into it? Would love to hear everyone’s thoughts.
Has anyone else come across information regarding the revolver found on the Penguin? I’ve been digging through some old newspaper archives, and it seems like this particular piece of evidence wasn’t discussed as extensively as it might deserve. The gun was reportedly found amid a chaotic scene aboard the Penguin, and yet there’s been surprisingly little speculation about its origins or how it ties into the overall narrative of what happened that night.
Given that Benjamin was bound and thrown overboard, it makes me wonder if the gun belonged to him or the attackers. Could it have been self-defense gone wrong? Or was it simply part of the intimidation tactics used by the perpetrators? I've seen some folks suggest it may have been planted to throw off investigators. It’s just another layer to this tragic case that leaves me with so many questions. Would be interested to hear if anyone has come across any new details or thoughts about the revolver’s role in all of this. My heart goes out to the Collings family—this must have been such a painful and frustrating ordeal.