Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Forum Posts for John Matthew DeFeo:
Be respectful. Abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

I've always found it really unsettling that the entire DeFeo family was found face down in their beds. It makes you wonder why none of them seemed to have woken up or tried to defend themselves. Was there any evidence that they were drugged or something? I can't imagine how terrifying it must have been if they did wake up and realized what was happening. The thought of those poor kids, especially little John Matthew, just makes my heart ache. It's so tragic that their lives ended in such a violent and abrupt way. Does anyone know if there was any concrete evidence about how they were forced to stay in bed like that? I'm curious if this angle was ever explored in detail during the investigation or if we’ll ever truly understand what happened in those final moments.
Has anyone else been digging into the dynamics within the DeFeo family leading up to that fateful night? I've been thinking a lot about young John Matthew, just nine years old, and what life might have been like for him. Moving from Brooklyn to Amityville, you'd imagine it was supposed to be a fresh start, a chance for a brighter future. It's gut-wrenching to think how his life ended so violently at the hands of his own brother. Even the community they moved to, known for its affluence, couldn't shield them from such inner turmoil. It makes you wonder what signs, if any, were overlooked or ignored. It's important for us to remember John Matthew and his family, not just for the tragedy, but for the promise of life that was stolen from them. Sending thoughts to anyone who knew them personally.
I've been thinking a lot about the DeFeo family and their move to Amityville. They initially sought a fresh start in a lovely Long Island community. It's devastating to think about how they were looking for a place to make new memories and find happiness, only for their lives to be senselessly taken in such a horrific way.
I can't stop wondering about the impact this must have had on the community. Amityville is quite close-knit, from what I've heard, and I can only imagine the feeling of shock and fear that must have washed over the neighborhood. It’s a small piece of the tragedy, but everyone who knew the family or lived nearby likely carries some of the weight from that night, even all these years later. I hope that over time, they've been able to find some form of peace, though I'm sure the memory lingers.
The case also serves as a grim reminder of how we can never truly know what goes on behind closed doors. Did anyone see warning signs in Ronald Jr. and ignore them? It's haunting to think that maybe someone could have intervened. My thoughts are with those who knew and loved the DeFeos and who have had to carry on in the wake of such a loss.