Paul Todesco Missing Person Case

On a spring day in May of 1981, 29-year-old Paul Daniel Todesco was with Rob Garrett in Seward, Alaska. The two men were on Kenai Lake near Porcupine Island when they were involved in a boating accident. An exact date for this incident has not been publicly released, making the sequence of events somewhat vague. At the time of his disappearance, Paul was described as a white male, standing at 5 feet 11 inches tall and weighing approximately 195 pounds. He had brown, medium-long hair and brown eyes. A notable characteristic was a scar on his right arm. The clothing he was last seen wearing consisted of blue jeans, a black and red checkered coat, and Nike running shoes.

Following the boating accident, a search of the area was initiated. While the boat, its motor, and a backpack were recovered, there was unfortunately no sign of Paul Todesco or Rob Garrett. The Alaska State Troopers were the investigating agency for this case, with a report being filed the day after the incident is believed to have occurred. Despite the efforts of search teams, the vast and challenging Alaskan wilderness yielded no further clues as to the whereabouts of the two men. The unforgiving nature of Kenai Lake and the surrounding terrain likely presented significant obstacles to the search and recovery operations.

The disappearance of Paul Daniel Todesco and Rob Garrett has left a lasting void for their families and friends. With no further evidence or leads discovered since the initial search, their case has grown cold over the decades. The lack of resolution has meant that their loved ones have had to endure the profound pain of not knowing what truly happened on that day in May 1981. The case serves as a somber reminder of the inherent dangers of boating, especially in the unpredictable and often treacherous waters of Alaska. The overview of this case is one of a tragic accident followed by an unsuccessful search, leaving behind a painful and enduring mystery.
Last Seen: May 20, 1981

Missing Person / NamUs

Paul Todesco Missing Person Flyer | Seward, Alaska | CaseTrace