Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 1 source
On a summer day in Berthoud, Colorado, two-year-old Shay Smith was at Carter Lake with his father, Gil Smith, on July 15, 2006. This outing turned tragic, as it was the last time Shay was ever seen. Initial reports were confused, but it was later clarified that Shay had been on a "Super Screamer" inner tube-style raft. His father was towing the tube with a boat at speeds estimated to be between 20 and 30 miles per hour. Tragically, the little boy fell from the tube into the water. The life jacket he was wearing was too large for him and was later found in the lake with one of its buckles undone.

The immediate aftermath of Shay's disappearance led to extensive search efforts in Carter Lake, but these searches yielded no sign of the young boy. Tragically, his body has never been recovered. The investigation into the circumstances of his disappearance revealed unsettling details. It was reported that no adult was directly watching Shay while he was on the tube being pulled by the boat. Instead, his three-year-old brother had reportedly been tasked with watching over him. This information, coupled with the initial conflicting reports from his father, painted a grim picture of the events that transpired that day.

In the years following Shay's disappearance, the case has remained a painful open wound for those who remember the little boy. The official investigation led to legal consequences for Shay's father, Gil Smith, who pleaded guilty to child abuse resulting in death. The case is a somber reminder of the importance of water safety and vigilant supervision of young children. Although officially classified as a missing person case, the prevailing belief is that Shay drowned in Carter Lake that day. Without the recovery of his body, a definitive conclusion remains elusive, leaving a lingering sense of sorrow and unanswered questions. Anyone with information regarding the case is encouraged to contact the Larimer County Sheriff's Office.

Last Seen: Jul 15, 2006

Links to Additional Sources (1)

See any mistakes? Let us know!