On August 6, 2020, 67-year-old Allen Boy McGee was last known to be in Butler, a rural community in Johnson County, Tennessee. McGee was a White male with brown hair and brown eyes, stood approximately 6 feet 1 inch tall, and weighed between 205 and 215 pounds. He had facial hair and was reportedly living at a property owned by David Lee Albright, who was also described by authorities as McGee's roommate. When McGee abruptly disappeared and could no longer be contacted, the silence surrounding him caused immediate concern among those who knew him. He was reported missing soon afterward, and the Johnson County Sheriff's Office began investigating with assistance from the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation.
One of the earliest and most troubling developments was the discovery of McGee's vehicle away from his residence. The vehicle was found abandoned at an old quarry, drawing investigators to an isolated location where the terrain and surroundings presented difficult questions about how the vehicle had arrived there and what may have happened afterward. Authorities searched the quarry area multiple times in an effort to locate McGee or uncover evidence explaining his disappearance. Despite those searches, no publicly reported discovery provided his location, and no lead developed from the site was sufficient to bring the search to an end. The abandoned vehicle remained a central piece of the investigation, but McGee himself was still missing.
As investigators examined the circumstances at McGee's residence and reconstructed the period before he vanished, their attention turned to Albright. About a week after McGee was reported missing, authorities executed a search warrant at the residence and on the surrounding property. The Johnson County Sheriff's Office subsequently announced its belief that Albright was responsible for McGee's disappearance. Albright was arrested and charged with first-degree murder, tampering with evidence, and abuse of a corpse, in addition to other alleged offenses. These were criminal accusations based on the investigative theory presented by law enforcement, and the charges did not change the painful reality that McGee had not been found.
Albright remained in custody while the investigation continued, and reports emphasized that the search for McGee was still active despite the murder charge. Authorities were therefore pursuing a case in which they believed McGee had died, yet they had not recovered him or publicly established where his remains might be. The absence of a recovery left an important part of the case unresolved. For McGee's loved ones, the arrest may have offered some indication that investigators believed they understood what had happened, but it could not provide the certainty or opportunity for a proper farewell that locating him might have brought.
The publicly available information does not describe the complete body of evidence that led investigators to accuse Albright. It also does not establish in detail what authorities believed occurred inside or near the residence, how McGee's vehicle came to be abandoned at the quarry, or where McGee was taken afterward. What is clear is that law enforcement treated the disappearance as far more than a routine missing-person inquiry. The execution of a search warrant, Albright's arrest on serious charges, continued searches for McGee, and repeated appeals for information showed that investigators believed someone might still possess knowledge capable of revealing where he was.
McGee's case is recorded by the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System as MP129511 and is investigated by the Johnson County Sheriff's Office under agency case number 20-1294. A family DNA reference sample was submitted to support identification efforts should relevant remains or evidence ever be located. Authorities have continued to ask anyone with information about McGee's disappearance, the movement or abandonment of his vehicle, the quarry, or events at his residence to contact the Johnson County Sheriff's Office at 423-727-7761. Every credible detail could be important in helping investigators locate him and provide long-awaited answers.
Allen McGee's disappearance remains a deeply distressing story of an older man who vanished from his home community, a vehicle found abandoned at an old quarry, repeated searches that failed to locate him, and an investigation that led to the arrest of his roommate and landlord. Although authorities publicly accused another man of causing McGee's death and concealing what happened, McGee remained missing, leaving his family and community with an incomplete resolution. In overview, the case began with the unexplained disappearance of a 67-year-old Butler man on August 6, 2020, developed through the discovery of his abandoned vehicle and searches of a quarry, and became a suspected homicide investigation in which a defendant was held in custody while the search for Allen McGee continued.
Last Seen: Aug 06, 2020
