In the small community of Middleton, Michigan, the story of Glenn Richard Hustin, Jr., known to his friends and family as Lenny, is a somber tale of a man who vanished under troubling circumstances. On the evening of February 5, 2001, the 30-year-old was last seen at his residence on North Caroline Street. A coworker from the Fulton Country Corners gas station, where he was a dedicated employee, had given him a ride home that day.
Glenn, a man described as happy and sociable despite being developmentally disabled, was expected at work the following morning but never arrived. This uncharacteristic absence was the first sign that something was gravely wrong. At the time of his disappearance, he was wearing a blue and green flannel jacket, jeans, and athletic shoes. He also wore distinctive jewelry: a silver mood ring, a silver Avon ring with a diamond, and a silver watch.
The days following Glenn’s disappearance only deepened the mystery and concern. A week after he was last seen, he was scheduled to testify as a witness in a criminal case against his landlord and employer, Roger Eugene Brown. Hustin had reportedly witnessed Brown stealing a rifle and a bow from another tenant's apartment and had also seen Brown assault a child in his own apartment. Initially, Glenn told police that Brown had not taken anything, but later changed his story, admitting he had been afraid. Due to Glenn's disappearance, the key witness was absent, and the larceny charges against Brown were ultimately dismissed. Brown did, however, plead guilty to the assault charge and was fined. Two weeks after Glenn vanished, his blue bicycle with a wire basket was found abandoned in Ithaca, Michigan, but there was no sign of Glenn himself.
The investigation into Glenn's disappearance has been fraught with difficulties and few leads. His apartment was found intact, with his clean laundry sitting by the door, suggesting he did not plan to leave. Over the years, numerous tips and theories have been explored by the Michigan State Police, including the possibility that he had traveled to Florida or Kentucky, but none of these leads have been substantiated. His sister's own attempts to investigate were met with intimidation, including threats and vandalism to her car, forcing her to abandon her efforts for her own safety. Since he went missing, there has been no activity on Glenn's Social Security number, and none of his government assistance or income tax refund checks have been cashed. The case of Glenn Hustin Jr. remains an open and frustrating one for law enforcement and a source of unending pain for his family, who believe he met with foul play. His disappearance, just before he was to testify in a criminal case, continues to be a central and suspicious element in the ongoing mystery.
Glenn Richard Hustin, Jr., a 30-year-old male also known by the nicknames Lenny, Glenny, and Len, was last seen on February 5, 2001, in Middleton, Michigan, in Gratiot County. He was last known to be at his residence near Davis and Caroline Street, with public accounts placing him more specifically in the area of North Caroline Street. The final known moments before his disappearance were ordinary on the surface: Glenn, who worked at the Fulton Country Corners gas station, usually rode his bicycle to and from work, but that day he had left the bicycle at the gas station and accepted a ride home from a female coworker. She dropped him off at his residence, and after that, no confirmed sighting of him has ever explained where he went.
Glenn was described in public missing-person records as a White / Caucasian man, about 5 feet 5 inches tall and approximately 115 pounds, with brown hair and brown eyes. He may have been wearing a goatee, and he wore gold wire-framed glasses. He had a scar on the top of his head and a birthmark on his neck, details that could help distinguish him if he were ever found or compared to unidentified-person records. At the time he disappeared, he was reportedly wearing a blue and green flannel jacket, jeans, and athletic shoes. He was also described as wearing a silver mood ring, a silver Avon ring with a diamond, and a silver watch. These personal details are part of what remains of the public record, preserving the image of the man his family knew before his life became a mystery.
The concern became immediate when Glenn did not arrive for work on the morning of February 6, 2001. Public sources describe that as uncharacteristic of him, especially because his routine was simple and predictable. When his apartment was checked, it reportedly showed no obvious signs of a struggle or forced disturbance. His clean laundry was said to have been sitting near the door, a small but haunting detail because it suggested an interrupted life rather than a planned disappearance. His bank account reportedly has not been touched since he vanished, adding to the belief among those close to the case that he did not simply leave to start over somewhere else.
The case carried another troubling layer because Glenn was expected to appear as a witness in an upcoming criminal case. Public accounts state that he was scheduled to testify against his landlord and employer, Roger Eugene Brown, in connection with allegations involving the theft of weapons from another tenant’s apartment and an assault involving a child. Glenn had reportedly first told police that Brown had not taken anything, then later changed his account and said he had been afraid. Because Glenn disappeared before he could testify, the case connected to that testimony was reportedly affected, and the timing of his disappearance has remained one of the most concerning elements of the investigation. Public information does not show that anyone has been charged in Glenn’s disappearance, but the circumstances have long raised questions about whether his role as a witness may have mattered.
About two weeks after Glenn vanished, his bicycle was found abandoned near a trucking company warehouse in Ithaca, Michigan. It was described in public reporting as a blue girls’ bicycle with a wire basket on the front. That discovery was unusual because Glenn had reportedly left the bicycle at work before accepting the ride home on the night he was last seen. How the bicycle came to be found later in Ithaca, and whether Glenn himself moved it or someone else did, remains unclear from the available public record. The bicycle became one of the few physical clues in the case, but it did not lead to a confirmed location for Glenn or a public explanation of what happened after he was dropped off at home.
The Michigan State Police has been listed as the investigating agency, with the Lakeview Post associated with the case and agency case number 14-217-01. NamUs lists Glenn as Missing Person case MP823, and family DNA has been collected for comparison purposes, showing that the case remains searchable through modern missing-person and unidentified-person systems. No public resolution has been reported, and no public source reviewed identifies a confirmed suspect, arrest, or recovery. In overview, Glenn Hustin, Jr.’s case is the story of a 30-year-old Middleton man last seen after being dropped off at home on February 5, 2001, whose sudden absence from work the next morning, his pending role as a witness in a criminal case, and the later discovery of his abandoned bicycle left behind a deeply troubling mystery that remains unresolved.Last Seen: Feb 5, 2001
