Isabel Rizzo Missing Person Case

Sep 08, 2011

Sep 13, 2022

Isabel

Rizzo

72

34

63 inches

160 lbs

White / Caucasian

Female

In the late autumn of 1987, a family in New Rochelle, New York, was forever altered by a sudden and mysterious disappearance. On November 23rd, 34-year-old Isabel Rizzo, a wife and mother to an infant daughter, vanished from her home. The circumstances of her disappearance began to unfold in the early morning hours when her husband, Frank Rizzo, reported returning home at 2:30 a.m. to a deeply unsettling scene. He told authorities that he found his baby daughter alone in her crib, with no sign of his wife. The familiar comforts of their home held a new, chilling silence, as everything Isabel would have needed to start a new life, or even just to step out for a short while, had been left behind. Her identification, money, credit cards, and handbag were all untouched, suggesting she had not planned to leave. The initial investigation into Isabel's whereabouts yielded few answers, deepening the mystery surrounding her sudden absence. A significant but grim discovery was made on December 10, 1987, when Isabel's car was found burned out at the Baychester Avenue entrance to Interstate 95 North in the Bronx. This finding pointed towards a violent end to her journey, but it provided no direct evidence as to what had happened to her. Her husband suggested to investigators that she might have returned to her native Chile, but this lead was quickly dismissed when her family there confirmed they had not seen or heard from her. With no signs of a voluntary departure and a lack of communication, the hope of her safe return began to diminish with each passing day. As years turned into decades, the case of Isabel Rizzo grew cold, though suspicion of foul play lingered heavily among investigators. Despite their beliefs, authorities were never able to gather enough evidence to press charges against any specific individual in connection with her disappearance. A dark turn of events many years later cast a renewed shadow of suspicion on Isabel's husband. In 2006, Frank Rizzo was convicted for the murder of his girlfriend, Carmella LaPuma. While this conviction highlighted a capacity for violence, it did not produce the evidence needed to officially link him to his wife's long-unsolved case. The overview of this case is one of profound and unanswered loss; a young mother disappeared from the perceived safety of her home, leaving behind an infant daughter and a trail of disturbing questions. The discovery of her burned car pointed to a criminal act, and while her husband's later criminal conviction raised serious concerns, the lack of direct evidence has left Isabel Rizzo's disappearance an unsolved mystery, and her ultimate fate unknown.

Nov 23, 1987

New Rochelle

New York

Westchester County

10801

10740

New Rochelle Police Department

New Rochelle

New York

Westchester County

10801

475 North Avenue, New York

9146542300

Local

Law Enforcement

https://www.newrochelleny.com/police

40856-87

New Rochelle Police Department

Brown

Brown

Brown

08/25/2026