Account
Feb 13, 2013
Feb 27, 2019
Charles
Conner
103
37
72 inches
74 inches
200 lbs
220 lbs
White / Caucasian
Male
In the summer of 1957 in Lima, Ohio, the life of Charles "Chuck" Conner, a 37-year-old factory foreman, took a tragic and mysterious turn. On the evening of August 10th, which was also his birthday, Conner was at the home of Ralph Forsythe, located in the 200 block of east McKibben Street. Along with three other men, they were drinking in the kitchen when the atmosphere shifted dramatically. Forsythe accused Conner of stealing a gun and, in a sudden act of violence, shot him in the head. The other men present fled the house in a state of panic. One of the witnesses later entered a local bar and recounted the horrific event to the bartender. Initially, police were skeptical of the account, especially since the other witnesses did not come forward until the next day. When law enforcement arrived at Forsythe's residence, they found no trace of Forsythe, his wife, or Charles Conner. However, the scene in the kitchen told a grim story, with bloodstains and a bullet hole in the wall providing silent evidence of the violence that had occurred. Approximately 24 hours after the shooting, Ralph Forsythe was located and arrested. The investigation that followed led to his trial, and in December 1957, he was convicted of manslaughter. A crucial piece of evidence came from a caretaker of a park in Cadiz, about 200 miles east of Lima. The caretaker testified to seeing Forsythe and his wife washing out their Ford Courier. Left behind at the park were blood-stained rags, clothing, and newspapers. When authorities eventually found the vehicle, they discovered it contained water and human blood. Despite the conviction, the story did not end there. Forsythe maintained that he had only been joking and that the gun was loaded with blanks. In 1967, his manslaughter conviction was overturned on procedural grounds. By that time, many of the witnesses had passed away and crucial evidence had been lost, leading the state to decide against a retrial. Ralph Forsythe was released from custody and died in 1983, reportedly never revealing what he did with Charles Conner's body. Just two weeks before his disappearance, Conner had gone through a divorce. Tragically, his ex-wife died in a fire in 1960, and his parents passed away years later without ever knowing what happened to their son. The case remains a sorrowful mystery, a story of a life cut short and a family left with unanswered questions. The search for Conner has never officially ended, leaving a void in the lives of those who knew him and a lingering question in the community he called home.
Aug 10, 1957
Lima
Ohio
Allen County
31269
Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation
London
Ohio
Madison County
43140
Samantha Molnar
Criminal Intelligence Analyst
1560 State Route 56 Southwest, Ohio
State
Law Enforcement
19245 BCI
Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation
Black
Blue
Blue
05/28/2026
