Account
Oct 08, 2013
Jul 17, 2019
Cathy
Hawley
74
41
68 inches
142 lbs
White / Caucasian
Female
In the quiet community of Gaylord, Michigan, 41-year-old Cathy Ann Hawley, a dedicated physical therapist at Otsego Memorial Hospital, vanished without a trace in the late winter of 1992. While some accounts state she was last seen on February 28, others record the date as March 3. What is known is that she was last seen at her condominium in the Maple Ridge Estates. In the years since she was last seen, her case has grown cold, leaving her loved ones with unanswered questions and a profound sense of loss. Investigators strongly suspect she was a victim of foul play and treat her disappearance as a homicide, a belief that has shaped the direction of their long-standing investigation. The day Cathy Hawley disappeared was a significant one for her; she had just finalized her divorce from John Vincent Hyland Jr. and had been awarded a financial settlement. A restraining order was also granted, prohibiting Hyland from having any contact with her at her place of work. After leaving the courthouse, she returned to her job and was not seen again after that evening. Despite her ex-husband being the primary suspect in her disappearance, he was reportedly out of town at the time she went missing. This has not deterred investigators from focusing on him, given the timing of her disappearance coinciding with the contentious divorce settlement. The circumstances surrounding the day she vanished suggest a motive connected to the recent legal proceedings. In the weeks and years that followed Cathy's disappearance, her case remained without a significant breakthrough. Her body has never been recovered, and no one has ever been charged in connection with her presumed death. Roughly six weeks after she was last seen, her ex-husband, John Hyland, was arrested on charges of sexually assaulting his two young daughters in 1991. He was subsequently convicted and sentenced to a lengthy prison term of 18 to 27 years. Later, in 2011, Hyland faced further legal trouble and was convicted of failing to register as a sex offender. Over the decades, investigators have looked into unidentified remains in hopes of a match, but none have been Cathy Hawley. The case is an overview of a heart-wrenching mystery where a woman disappeared on a day that should have marked a new beginning for her. It is believed she was the victim of a homicide, and though a prime suspect was identified early on, the lack of physical evidence and a body has left the case unsolved, a lingering cold case that continues to await a resolution.
Mar 03, 1992
Gaylord
Michigan
Otsego County
14327
Michigan State Police
Gaylord
Michigan
Otsego County
49735
David Hart
D/Sgt.
Gaylord Post, Michigan
9897322778
State
Law Enforcement
73-479-92
Michigan State Police
Brown
Blue
Blue
06/01/2026
