Crime Solvers Central
CSC
251 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Sheila Sullivan, 40 years old, was last seen on August 17, 1994, in Columbus, Ohio. Her disappearance remains a mystery, with few details available about the circumstances surrounding that day. Standing between 5'5" and 5'9", and weighing approximately 105 to 120 pounds, Sheila had blonde hair and green eyes. She also had multiple surgical scars, including a noticeable scar across her neck from thyroid surgery, as well as scars on her head and chest, and scars near her ears from jaw surgery.
...Read More
Last Seen: Aug 17, 1994

Victim Details

Jun 08, 2014

Jan 04, 2024

Sheila

Sullivan

70

40

69 inches

120 lbs

White / Caucasian

Female

In the late summer of 1994, a 40-year-old woman named Sheila Sullivan vanished from Columbus, Ohio. She was last seen on August 17, 1994, and afterward, no one reported hearing from her again. Originally from Mize, Mississippi, Sheila had connections to her home state, even though she was living in Ohio at the time of her disappearance. Physically, she was a white female with blonde hair and green eyes, standing between 5'5" and 5'9" and weighing between 105 and 120 pounds. Her appearance was marked by several distinct features, including pierced ears and multiple surgical scars on her head, chest, and neck, with additional minor scars near her ears from a past jaw surgery. The circumstances surrounding the day Sheila Sullivan was last seen are not widely publicized, and there is very little official information available about her disappearance. For years, her case has remained open with few details emerging to provide a clear picture of what might have happened. The lack of information has been a significant challenge for those seeking answers. The Columbus Division of Police is the investigating agency responsible for her case. Despite the passage of time, advocacy groups, particularly in her home state of Mississippi, have worked to keep her story alive in the public consciousness. A significant, though unconfirmed, claim emerged from a relative of the man Sheila was dating at the time she went missing. The cousin of her boyfriend alleged that the boyfriend had murdered Sheila and buried her body in a pasture in Mt. Olive, Mississippi. However, investigators have not been able to officially confirm this disturbing allegation. This has left her family and community without closure. The case of Sheila Sullivan is a somber reminder of a life interrupted, a woman who disappeared leaving behind only lingering questions and an investigation that continues decades later in the hope of one day finding the truth.

Aug 17, 1994

Columbus

Ohio

Franklin County

23316

Columbus Division of Police

Columbus

Ohio

Franklin County

43215

Charles Radich

Detective

120 Marconi Boulevard, Ohio

6146454545

Local

Law Enforcement

62657-94

Columbus Division of Police

Sandy

Green

Green

05/23/2026


Area Last Seen: