206 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Matthew Milton

Missing
Case Description
Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Matthew Milton, a 32-year-old scuba diver from Winter Springs, Florida, went missing on November 2, 2014, while diving off the coast of Islamorada in the Florida Keys. Milton was out on a 23-foot boat with his brother-in-law, Jeff Stewart. After surfacing from a dive, the two realized their boat had drifted away. Both attempted to swim toward the boat, but they became separated in the water. Stewart managed to reach a mooring buoy, where he was later rescued by the U.S. Coast Guard. Unfortunatel ...Read More
Last Seen: Nov 02, 2014
Links to Additional Sources (4)
See any mistakes? Let us know!
  • Crews search for missing diver in Florida Keys - WESH
  • Orlando man missing after dive trip - News4JAX
    •     ...View 2 additional sources
    Victim Details

    Jan 29, 2015

    Apr 05, 2019

    Matthew

    Milton

    42

    32

    72 inches

    180 lbs

    190 lbs

    White / Caucasian

    Male

    Nov 02, 2014

    Islamorada

    Florida

    Monroe County

    32708

    349

    16217

    Monroe Co. Sheriff's Office

    Key West

    Florida

    ,

    MCSO14OFF08260

    Monroe Co. Sheriff's Office

    Brown

    Brown

    Brown

    11/13/2025


    Area Last Seen:
    Forum Posts (1)
    Does anyone have any insight on the ocean currents around Islamorada during the time Matthew Milton ... ...Read More
    04/04/2024
    Other Missing Cases from Islamorada, Florida

    Jay Hegeman

    Missing: Oct 06, 2023
    Jay Hegeman, a 74-year-old resident of Islamorada, Florida, was reported missing after last being se ...Read More