206 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.
Case Description
Any updates on this case?
Matthew Fagan, a 23-year-old man, went missing on June 21, 2016, while hiking near the Cato Creek/Buzzard Roost area of Lake Tenkiller, Oklahoma. He was hiking with a group of friends when he reportedly turned back due to leg pain. When the group returned, Fagan had not arrived at the vehicle, and search efforts, including the use of dogs and horseback riders, began shortly afterward. Authorities grew suspicious due to conflicting reports from Fagan's friends, and his disappearance is being inve ...Read More
Last Seen: Jun 21, 2016
Last Seen: Jun 21, 2016
Links to Additional Sources (8)
See any mistakes?Victim Details
Jun 28, 2016
Jan 12, 2024
Matthew
Fagan
31
23
68 inches
160 lbs
White / Caucasian
Male
Jun 21, 2016
Cato Creek hiking area
Oklahoma
Sequoyah County
267
5970
Sequoyah County Sheriff's Office
Sallisaw
Oklahoma
Sequoyah County
74955
Charles House
Chief Deputy
119 South Oak Street, Oklahoma
9187759155
County
Law Enforcement
16-01072
2016-06-22
Sequoyah County Sheriff's Office
Brown
Blue
Blue
11/30/2025
Area Last Seen:
Forum Posts (2)
Has anyone else looked into the weather conditions on the day Matthew Fagan went missing? June 21, 2... ...Read More
01/17/2024
01/17/2024
Hey everyone, just stumbled upon something odd about Matthew Fagan's case while going through old ma... ...Read More
01/04/2023
01/04/2023
