John Paciulli Missing from Patchogue, New York age 24

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!

John Paciulli, 24, went missing on July 10, 1971, while fishing in the Atlantic Ocean off the coast of Fire Island, near Oak Beach, New York. His boat was later discovered submerged by divers, but his body was never recovered. Paciulli had been out fishing alone, and the circumstances surrounding his disappearance remain a mystery. Despite extensive search efforts, no further evidence was found, and his case remains unsolved. Authorities continue to list Paciulli as missing, and any new informat ...Read More
Last Seen: Jul 10, 1971

Links to Additional Sources (1)

See any mistakes? Let us know!

Missing Person / NamUs #MP59594

Victim Details

created

Aug 22, 2019

Case Added

Sep 12, 2019

firstname

John

lastname

Paciulli

Current Age

77

Age at Disappearance

24

Height

72 inches

Weight

150 lbs

Weight To

160 lbs

ethnicity

White / Caucasian

gender

Male

Last Seen

Jul 10, 1971

City

Patchogue

State

New York

County

Suffolk County

Zip Code

11772

Tribal Land

No

vehicles

251

Agency ID

61198

Agency Name

Suffolk County Police Department

Agency City

Yaphank

Agency State

New York

Agency County

Suffolk County

Agency Zip Code

11980

Agency Contact

Agency Address

30 Yaphank Ave, New York

Agency Phone

6318526110

Agency Jurisdiction

Local

Agency Type

Law Enforcement

Agency Case #

71-154635

Primary Agency

Suffolk County Police Department

caseContributors

na

Hair Color

Brown

Left Eye Color

Brown

Right Eye Color

Brown

solved

No

Last Updated

11/30/2025

Area Last Seen:

John Paciulli
Missing

Case Description

Links to Additional Sources (1)

Victim Details

Forum Posts (1)

Other Missing Cases from New York