Shadows Over the Plains: The Unresolved Disappearance of Penny Peeler from Enid

Who Was Penny Peeler?

Penny Yvonne Peeler was a 37-year-old mother and Oklahoma resident whose life, workaday and unassuming, gave no warning of the mystery that would follow. Described as 5'6" to 5'7" and about 150 pounds, she had blonde or strawberry-blonde hair and blue to hazel eyes. She wore contact lenses and may have had a faint scar on her forehead. On the day she was last seen, she was reportedly dressed in a red flowered blouse, cut-off denim shorts, and brown sandals—details that have persisted across case summaries for decades.

A Last Phone Call and Growing Marital Strain

The final confirmed contact anyone had with Penny came on April 25, 1990, when she phoned her mother in Arkansas. During that call, she said she and her husband, Glenn “Bud” Peeler Jr., were having marital problems. It was an ordinary family check-in transformed into a historical marker; after that conversation, the trail grows uncertain and contested, setting the stage for a case defined by conflicting accounts....Read More

Share

Comments (0)

Leave A Comment