On a spring day in Hotchkiss, Colorado, a sequence of events unfolded that would end in the tragic death of 26-year-old Paige Pierce Schmidt. On April 9, 2021, a deputy from the Delta County Sheriff's Office attempted to pull over the white Honda Accord that Paige was driving because it did not have license plates. This seemingly routine traffic stop quickly escalated into a high-speed chase.
The pursuit weaved through Highway 92 and onto a private road. In an attempt to end the chase, spike strips were deployed, which successfully deflated the tires of Paige's vehicle. Following this, Deputy Nolan Davis exited his patrol truck with the intention of pursuing her on foot. It was at this critical juncture that the situation took a fatal turn. According to the District Attorney's report, Paige drove her car towards the deputy. In what was later described as an act of self-defense, Deputy Davis fired eight shots into her vehicle, striking and killing her.
The aftermath of the shooting was fraught with grief and controversy. Paige's family vehemently disputed the official account, calling for justice and expressing their belief that her death was unjust. They maintained that she was simply scared and that the situation did not need to end with lethal force. Protests were held, with family and supporters chanting for accountability.
Following an investigation into the incident, the District Attorney announced that no criminal charges would be filed against Deputy Nolan Davis. The district attorney concluded that the deputy acted in self-defense, believing his life was in danger as Paige's vehicle accelerated towards him. Body camera footage from the scene was released, although the audio was missing for the initial 30 seconds. Eyewitness accounts, including that of a civilian on a ride-along with the deputy, were also considered in the investigation. Despite the official ruling, the family of Paige Pierce Schmidt continues to mourn their loss and question the actions that led to her death.
