Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
In the pre-dawn hours of Friday, June 3, 2016, a grim discovery was made on a busy stretch of highway in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. In a sedan stopped on Route 65, near the McKees Rocks Bridge on the city’s North Side, two young men were found shot to death. One of them was Carlton Free-watson, a 24-year-old African-American man from the city's Hazelwood neighborhood. He was also known to some as Carlton Watson Jr.

The call came into police shortly before 5 a.m. Responding officers found Carlton and the other victim, 26-year-old Richard West-Gray, inside the vehicle. Both men had sustained multiple gunshot wounds. Officers attempted to perform CPR, but paramedics pronounced both Carlton and Richard dead at the scene. The double homicide prompted Pittsburgh Police to shut down a section of the major highway for hours as detectives and forensic teams processed the crime scene, searching for any evidence that could lead them to who was responsible for the violent killings.

In the weeks and months that followed, the investigation struggled to gain momentum. Detectives from the Pittsburgh Police Department were faced with a lack of witnesses and few actionable leads. The public learned little about the circumstances that led to the shooting, and no suspects or persons of interest were ever publicly identified. The silence in the case was agonizing for the families of the two young men whose lives were so abruptly taken.

Four months after the murders, in October 2016, the mothers of both victims made a joint public plea for information. Standing together in their shared grief, Carlton's mother, Candice Watson, and Richard's mother, Louise Gray, begged for anyone with knowledge of the crime to come forward. They urged that providing information was not "snitching" but a moral obligation, a necessary step to bring justice for their sons and some measure of peace to their shattered families. Their emotional appeal highlighted the profound and lasting pain inflicted on the community by unsolved violence.

While more was shared publicly about Richard West-Gray’s life as a father and aspiring rap artist, much less is known about Carlton. His death at just 24 years old left a void for those who knew and loved him, their memories and stories not yet part of the public record. His life, like Richard's, was cut short before its full potential could be realized, leaving his family to navigate a future without him.

As of late 2016, the investigation into the murders of Carlton Free-watson and Richard West-Gray remains open but inactive. No arrests have ever been made, and the case has grown cold. The Pittsburgh Police Department continues to seek any information that could break the silence and provide long-awaited answers and justice for two families forever altered by a morning of violence on a city highway.

Links to Additional Sources (0)

See any mistakes? Let us know!