Dannie F. “Dink” May III was known for his smile and the joy he brought to those who knew him. In the summer of 2005, the 38-year-old Black man’s life was tragically cut short, leaving his loved ones with a void that has been compounded by years of unanswered questions. His death remains a lingering mystery, a cold case file in the records of the Columbus Division of Police.
The holiday weekend was just beginning when the discovery was made on Sunday, July 3, 2005. Dannie was found inside his car on the westbound exit ramp of Interstate 70 to Miller and Kelton Avenues in Columbus, Ohio. He had been fatally shot. The location, a busy interchange on the city's South Side, offered few immediate clues as to what had happened.
Police responded to the scene, and his death was quickly classified as a homicide, but the critical questions of who was responsible and why have remained elusive.
The investigation into Dannie’s murder was launched by the Columbus Division of Police. Detectives processed the scene on the highway ramp, searching for any piece of evidence that could point them toward a suspect or a motive. However, in the days and weeks that followed, no arrests were made, and no persons of interest were publicly identified. The flow of information slowed to a trickle, and the case, like so many others, began to grow cold. The lack of public updates left a painful silence for Dannie's family and friends.
In the aftermath of his death, those who loved Dannie gathered to mourn him. A funeral service was held on the evening of Monday, July 11, 2005, at a funeral home on Cleveland Avenue. The online guestbook for his obituary filled with messages of love and sorrow. One friend remembered a recent phone conversation, filled with "laughter and tears," that would now never be forgotten. Another message, from a childhood sweetheart, spoke to the deep roots he had in his community. Friends and family recalled his smile and his joy, with one tribute reading, "We will miss your smile; your joy; your life; forever." A message of sympathy was extended to "Lavanna and Mikayla," indicating the close family he left behind.
Years have passed since Dannie May was killed, but the case is not forgotten. His homicide is listed on the Ohio Attorney General's Unsolved Homicides database, a stark reminder that justice has not yet been served. The Columbus Division of Police Homicide Case Review Unit maintains the file, hoping that a new lead, a new piece of information, or a change of heart from someone who knows something might finally break the silence. The investigators rely on the public's help to solve these lingering cases and bring a measure of peace to families who have waited far too long for answers.
As of November 2026, the investigation into the murder of Dannie May is ongoing but inactive, pending new information. There is no publicly mentioned reward for information in this case. The Columbus Police Department urges anyone with details, no matter how insignificant they may seem, to come forward. Information can be directed to the Columbus Police Homicide Case Review Unit at (614) 645-4036 or Central Ohio Crime Stoppers at (614) 461-TIPS (8477). For a family left to navigate decades of grief, any tip could be the key to finally understanding what happened on that interstate ramp in the summer of 2005.