Anna Lee Chebetnoy was a 14-year-old girl from Puyallup, Washington, whose life was cut tragically short. Her case is one of several unsolved homicides involving young women that cast a shadow over the Puget Sound region in the late 1980s and early 1990s, a period when the community was still grappling with the horrors of the Green River killer.
Anna was last seen at a shopping center in her hometown of Puyallup. More than a year passed before her fate was known. On September 17, 1991, her skeletal remains were discovered by a survey crew working in a wooded area off Highway 410, east of Enumclaw in King County. The remote, forested location was disturbingly familiar to law enforcement. It was near the very same spot where the body of another teenager, 15-year-old Kimberly DeLange of Sumner, had been found three years earlier, in August 1988.
Kimberly had also been last seen at a Puyallup shopping center.
The grim discovery of Anna’s remains immediately drew the attention of detectives from both King and Pierce County. Investigators publicly noted the alarming similarities between the disappearances and deaths of Anna and Kimberly. The clustering of bodies in the area raised the specter of a serial predator. In addition to Anna and Kimberly, the remains of Marta Reeves were found off Highway 410 in 1990, and the unidentified remains of another young woman were found just six days before Anna, also near Highway 410, about 10 miles east of Enumclaw.
The Pierce County Sheriff's Department handled the investigation into Anna's death, viewing it as part of a deeply troubling pattern of unsolved murders of young women and girls in the region. At the time, authorities were examining more than 40 unsolved killings of women in King, Pierce, and Snohomish counties that had occurred since 1984, the year the Green River killer was believed to have stopped his spree. Many of the victims were teenagers or young women living vulnerable lives, their cases echoing the profile of the Green River victims.
Over the years, Anna’s case has grown cold, but it has not been forgotten by investigators. In July 2011, her murder was among a handful of Pierce County cold cases that were reviewed for any potential connection to Jack Daniel McCullough, a 71-year-old former police officer arrested for the 1957 murder of a young girl in Illinois. Detectives in both Pierce County and Tacoma pulled evidence from their coldest cases, including Anna's, hoping that advances in DNA technology might finally provide a link to a suspect. Detectives planned to re-examine evidence from decades prior, searching for the smallest trace of hair or DNA that might have been missed.
The area where Anna’s body was found, along the forested corridors of Highway 410 near the Mount Baker-Snoqualmie National Forest, became a dumping ground for multiple victims in that era. The grim discoveries left a lasting scar on the communities of Enumclaw, Puyallup, and Sumner, as families were left to wonder if a single killer was responsible for the string of deaths.
As of July 2011, the homicide of Anna Lee Chebetnoy remained one of Pierce County's unsolved crimes. Her killer has never been identified, and justice has remained elusive for her family. The investigation is ongoing, and authorities continue to seek information that could lead to a breakthrough in this decades-old case.