Brian Anderson was 31 years old and serving a 41-year sentence at the Washington State Reformatory in Monroe, Washington. The sentence was for a violent crime he committed in 1996 in the Spokane Valley, where he kidnapped and raped a woman, then tied her to a tree. Three years into his sentence, violence found him inside the prison walls. His family, regardless of his past, was left without answers about who took his life and why they have never been held accountable.
On the afternoon of August 11, 1999, at around 1:30 p.m., Brian was in the prison’s large, open yard when he was confronted by another inmate. According to witnesses who later spoke informally with investigators, the other prisoner demanded drugs from Brian. When Brian refused, the man punched him and ordered him to go get the drugs. Instead of complying, Brian walked away, heading into the prison gymnasium. Shortly after entering the gym, he collapsed in front of a guard.
He was rushed to a local hospital, where he died an hour later.
Initially, investigators suspected a drug overdose. Brian had made a comment about laced drugs shortly before he died, and marijuana was later found hidden in the soles of his tennis shoes. There were no obvious signs of trauma on his body. However, as inmate informers began to whisper that Brian had been assaulted, the focus of the investigation shifted. The Snohomish County Medical Examiner’s Office conducted an autopsy and made a grim discovery: Brian had died from severe internal bleeding caused by a lacerated liver, the result of a powerful blow to his body. By the time homicide was confirmed, it was too late to collect physical evidence from the yard where the attack occurred.
The investigation into the murder of Brian Anderson, a male inmate, was led by the Monroe Police Department with assistance from the state Department of Corrections. Authorities quickly came to believe the assault was the result of a drug robbery gone wrong. They were even confident they knew who was responsible. The problem was proving it. The case ran headfirst into the unwritten but strictly enforced inmate code of silence.
Investigators identified at least two inmates who witnessed the fatal assault. They provided an account of the confrontation over drugs but refused to sign official statements or agree to testify in court. "They have to live here," the lead Department of Corrections investigator said, acknowledging the fear of reprisal that kept witnesses from cooperating openly. Without formal testimony or physical evidence, the case stalled. At least four other men were believed to have seen the attack, but none would break the code. Prison video cameras did not capture the incident.
Years passed, and the case grew cold. In an effort to generate new leads for this and other unsolved homicides, the Snohomish County Sheriff’s Office created the state’s first deck of cold-case playing cards to distribute among inmates in jails and prisons. Brian Anderson’s story and photo were featured on the eight of diamonds. "Somebody did something to him that shouldn’t have been done," a Monroe police spokeswoman said in 2008. "His family deserves answers."
As of July 2008, Brian’s murder remained unsolved, and the case was classified as "open but inactive." Investigators hope that with the passage of time, someone who saw what happened might have a change of heart and finally come forward with the information needed to close the case. A reward of up to $1,000 is available for information leading to an arrest. Anyone with information is asked to call the anonymous tip line at 800-222-TIPS (8477) or the Snohomish County Sheriff's tip line at 425-388-3845.