In the summer of 1975, nineteen-year-old Carol Lothamer was building a new life for herself far from her hometown of Richmond, Indiana. She had moved to the seaside community of Middletown, Rhode Island, just eight months earlier and was already working as a hotel manager. It was a responsible position for a young woman starting out, but her independent new chapter would be brutally cut short.
On the evening of Thursday, August 21, 1975, Carol was seen visiting bars in the vibrant, historic city of Newport. It was the last time she was seen alive. Three days later, on Sunday, August 24, her body was discovered in a recreation area known as Carr Point, located on the grounds of Naval Station Newport. The scenic area, near Narragansett Bay in the town of Portsmouth, was under the jurisdiction of the U.S. Navy. An investigation determined that Carol had been badly beaten.
Due to the condition of her remains, it was clear she had been killed days before she was found.
Because Carol was found on federal property, the investigation into her homicide became the responsibility of the Naval Criminal Investigative Service (NCIS). From the beginning, information about the case has been exceptionally limited. Details about potential suspects, evidence recovered from the scene, or persons of interest have not been released to the public. Over the decades, journalists' requests for information from the federal agency have been denied, leaving Carol's family and the community with more questions than answers. This scarcity of public information has become a defining characteristic of the case.
The area where Carol was killed was not easily accessible to the general public, leading to speculation that her killer may have had a connection to the Navy. In the years that followed, other unsolved homicides of young women in the Newport area, such as the 1980 murder of 19-year-old Diane Drake, created a climate of fear and uncertainty in the community. However, no official connection between these cases has ever been established by law enforcement.
Decades have passed, but the quest for justice for Carol Lothamer has not been entirely abandoned. Her case is one of several featured in a cold case playing card deck distributed in Rhode Island correctional facilities. The project, a joint effort by the Rhode Island Attorney General's office and law enforcement agencies, aims to generate new leads from inmates who may have knowledge of unsolved crimes. Carol's face and the details of her case are on the Ace of Diamonds, a silent plea for information that might finally break the long-standing silence.
As of November 2019, Carol Lothamer's murder remains an open and unsolved investigation with NCIS. Very little is publicly known about the vibrant young woman who moved across the country to start a new life, only to have it stolen from her. Without new information, her case remains frozen in the summer of 1975, a painful mystery for a family that has waited more than four decades for answers.