A lifelong resident of Cumberland, Rhode Island, Stanley J. Stowik Sr. was known to many as "Stosh" and the unofficial "mayor of Indiana Avenue." The 80-year-old man was a U.S. Navy veteran who served in the Korean War and later worked for the town of Cumberland before retiring. He was a father to six children—four daughters and two sons—and a grandfather to six. Neighbors and friends remembered him as a fixture in the community, a great guy who could always be counted on for a greeting salute. He was a gardener, a character, and a social man who spent his Friday nights, as he did for years, at the American Legion Post 14 on Broad Street.
On the evening of Friday, October 9, 2015, Stowik followed his routine and spent time at the American Legion before heading home. Neighbors saw him return to his Indiana Avenue residence shortly before 10 p.m. They heard him start his tractor and then go inside, after which they heard nothing unusual.
When his children couldn't reach him the following day, Saturday, October 10, they requested a well-being check. Police discovered Stowik deceased inside his home, where he lived alone. The state medical examiner later determined the cause of death was homicidal violence. Police immediately stated that Stowik was specifically targeted and that the wider community was not in danger.
The Cumberland Police Department, assisted by the Rhode Island State Police and at times the FBI, launched an intensive investigation. The crime scene was processed for several days, a fact that later drew questions from reporters and frustration from Stowik's family, who felt the investigation was slow to start over the Columbus Day weekend. Investigators have remained tight-lipped about the specific details of how Stowik was killed, stating only that he was the victim of a violent attack. The family has expressed anguish over not knowing the cause of death, noting that police had used metal detectors at the scene.
Early in the investigation, police identified a person of interest: William Donnelly, Stowik’s next-door neighbor. Donnelly had a significant criminal history, including a 1982 murder conviction for killing his supervisor at a surgical supply company in Providence. He was sentenced to 18 years but was released in 1988 after his conviction was questioned over a psychiatric report. He was later convicted of embezzlement. About a month after Stowik's murder, Donnelly was arrested on separate charges related to a neighborhood break-in that occurred just before the killing, though those charges were later dismissed. Police have stated they believe they know who killed Stowik but have not made an arrest, citing the high standard of proof required for a conviction.
Over the years, Stowik's family has voiced their suffering and frustration with the lack of progress. They offered a $10,000 reward for information leading to an arrest. Cumberland Police Chief John Desmarais has repeatedly stated that the case is active and that he has hope for a prosecution. The lead investigator, Detective Lt. Pete Sweet, has continued to work the case for years. To generate new leads, Stowik’s case was featured as the two of hearts in Rhode Island's cold case playing card deck, an initiative police hoped would encourage people with information to come forward.
As of December 2023, the murder of Stanley Stowik Sr. remains unsolved. His children and community are still waiting for justice. The Cumberland Police Department continues to seek information from the public. Anyone with information is urged to contact the Cumberland Police Department at 401-333-2500 or email [email protected].