Keith Lamont Marsh II was a young man with a vibrant life and a promising future ahead of him. At 22 years old, the Columbus, Ohio, native was a father, and his family remembers him as someone who was full of life and potential. His mother, Karen Walker, later reflected on his youth and the bright future he had, a future that was stolen from him and his loved ones. The Black / African American man's sudden death left a void in the lives of his family, especially his daughter, who would grow up without her father.
The evening of Thursday, May 8, 2014, began like any other for Keith. Just before 11:00 p.m., he stepped outside his apartment at 223 Mayfair Boulevard in the Eastmoor neighborhood on the city's east side. Witnesses told police he had gone out for a cigarette break. At approximately 10:44 p.m., while he was outside, he was approached by an unknown individual or individuals. In a sudden act of violence, Keith was shot.
Despite being gravely wounded, he managed to struggle back inside his apartment, where he collapsed onto the kitchen floor. Emergency medical personnel from the Columbus Fire Division were dispatched to the scene, but his injuries were too severe. Keith Marsh II was pronounced dead right there in his home.
The Columbus Division of Police immediately launched a homicide investigation into Keith's death. Detectives arrived at the Mayfair Boulevard apartment complex to process the scene and speak with potential witnesses. The initial accounts were consistent: Keith had gone out for a smoke and was gunned down by an unidentified assailant who then fled. The motive for the shooting was not immediately clear, and with no suspect in custody, the case quickly grew cold. For years, investigators have been seeking viable tips from the public that could break the case open and provide a path to justice.
In the years that followed, Keith's family has been left with the frustration and pain of an unsolved murder. "He was so young and vibrant and had so much going for him," his mother, Karen Walker, shared in a 2019 interview. "We need justice for him, not just for him, for his daughter and his family, and for his daughter." The family's plea for answers has been echoed by law enforcement, who have repeatedly called on the community for assistance. His name is also listed in the obituary of his grandmother, Reather Marsh, who passed away in 2026, a painful reminder of the family members who have died without seeing justice for his killing.
As of May 2025, more than a decade after Keith was killed, his case remains unsolved. The Columbus Division of Police has not publicly identified any suspects or persons of interest. The lack of new information has left investigators and Keith's family in a state of limbo, waiting for the one crucial piece of information that could lead to an arrest. The case is a stark example of the enduring impact of gun violence and the long shadow it casts over families and communities.
Central Ohio Crime Stoppers continues to feature Keith's case, hoping to jog someone's memory or prick someone's conscience. A cash reward is being offered for any information that leads to the arrest and/or indictment of the person or persons responsible for this senseless crime. Authorities urge anyone with knowledge about the homicide of Keith Marsh II to come forward. All tips provided to Crime Stoppers are anonymous. The tip line can be reached by calling 614-461-TIPS (8477), and tips can also be submitted online at www.stopcrime.org.