Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 4 sources
Do you know who murdered Paul Noel?
Paul Anthony Noel Jr., a 22-year-old African-American man, was known to his loved ones as a person full of life and promise. He lived on Morreene Road in Durham, North Carolina, and was in the prime of his youth when his future was violently cut short. His death, along with that of his friend, left a void in the lives of those who knew and cared for him, a sudden and tragic loss that would ripple through the community for years to come.

The evening of Sunday, January 8, 2012, began like any other but ended in bloodshed. At approximately 9:12 p.m., a barrage of gunfire erupted at a residence located at 1212 Dawkins Street in Durham's North Durham neighborhood. An unknown assailant, or assailants, fired numerous shots directly into the house. Inside were Paul Noel and 24-year-old Timothy Deangelo McGhee, who lived at the Dawkins Street home. The hail of bullets struck both men, creating a scene of chaos and violence.

When Durham Police Department officers responded to the shooting call, they discovered a grim scene. Timothy McGhee was found inside the house, having already succumbed to his gunshot wounds. He was pronounced dead at the location. Paul Noel was found critically injured but still alive. Emergency medical services rushed him to the nearby Duke University Hospital, a place of healing that would, for Paul, become the place where he drew his last breath. Despite the efforts of the medical staff, he died from his injuries a short time after arriving.

The double homicide launched a major investigation by the Durham Police Department. In the initial stages, investigators determined that the shots were fired from outside the home, but the identity of the shooter or shooters remained a mystery. For more than three years, the case lingered, a painful open wound for the families of Paul Noel and Timothy McGhee, who waited for answers and justice. The case was listed among Durham's cold cases, a stark reminder of unresolved violence in the city.

A significant breakthrough finally came in the spring of 2015. After years of painstaking police work, investigators identified a suspect. In March 2015, the Durham Police Department charged 38-year-old Tyrone Thompson with two counts of murder for the deaths of Paul Noel and Timothy McGhee. The following month, on April 14, 2015, Thompson was located and apprehended. Members of a U.S. Marshals Fugitive Task Force took him into custody at about 6:30 a.m. in Goose Creek, South Carolina, a town nearly 300 miles from Durham.

Following his arrest, Thompson was held at the Berkeley County jail in South Carolina to await extradition back to North Carolina to face the murder charges. The arrest marked a pivotal moment in the long journey for justice, bringing a sense of hope to the families that the person allegedly responsible for the deaths of their loved ones would finally be held accountable in a court of law.

While the arrest represented a major step forward, the legal process is often slow and complex. The case against the accused individual would proceed through the court system, with the ultimate outcome pending trial. As of the latest available information, the case has moved into the litigation phase. For the community and the families of Paul Noel and Timothy McGhee, the memory of the two young men endures, their lives tragically cut short on a winter night. Authorities continue to encourage anyone with information about this or other unsolved cases to come forward. Durham CrimeStoppers offers cash rewards for information that leads to a felony arrest and can be reached at 919-683-1200. Callers can remain anonymous.