Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 1 source
In the turbulent summer of 1968, a year marked by social upheaval across the nation, the city of Cleveland was already grappling with deep-seated tensions. Just two months after the deadly Glenville shootout, a different kind of horror stunned the community. On the morning of September 16, 1968, the bodies of four people were discovered by early-morning joggers in the serene landscape of Rockefeller Park. They had been laid out side-by-side and executed with multiple gunshots from two different firearms.

One of the victims was Joseph Zoldman, a 54-year-old white male who owned a local tavern. Alongside him were three other victims: Raymond Homer, 26; Ronald Mahone, 22; and Martha Lancaster, who was 21 years old. Cleveland Police investigators quickly pieced together a grim theory: Zoldman, his two part-time bartenders, and Lancaster, a young woman, were likely taken hostage during a robbery at Zoldman's establishment. Authorities believed the kidnapper then drove them to the park and systematically murdered them to eliminate any witnesses to the initial crime. The cold-blooded nature of the killings sent a wave of shock and fear through the city.

The Cleveland Police launched an intensive investigation, but the case lacked immediate leads. The break would come a month later and more than a hundred miles away. On October 20, 1968, a lone gunman robbed a dairy bar in Columbus, Ohio, stealing $562. Before fleeing, he herded the manager, Phyllis Crowe, and two teenage employees, Susan Pack and Jimmy Stevens, into a back room. In a sudden explosion of rage, the robber declared he had nothing to lose and brutally attacked them, beating the teenagers and strangling Crowe with a coat hanger before shooting both Pack and Stevens in the head.

Phyllis Crowe miraculously survived the horrific assault. When she regained consciousness, she was able to provide police with a description of her attacker. Ballistics tests soon provided an undeniable link: one of the guns used in the Columbus murders was the same weapon used to kill Joseph Zoldman and the others in Rockefeller Park. From a series of mugshots, Crowe identified her assailant as Richard Lee Tingler Jr., a man with a lengthy and violent criminal record.

Born in December 1940, Tingler was a career criminal who had been in and out of prison for years on charges including burglary and parole violations, having been released most recently in February 1968. Following the positive identification, Tingler was indicted on six counts of murder. On November 8, 1968, he was added to the FBI’s Ten Most Wanted Fugitives list. By then, he had already fled Ohio, adopting the alias “Don Williams” and finding work as a farmhand in the small town of Dill City, Oklahoma.

Tingler’s attempt to lay low was undermined by his own paranoia and erratic behavior. His employer and neighbors grew wary of the new farmhand who was obsessed with firearms and prone to indiscriminate shooting. After his photo was featured on the television show "The FBI," Tingler became increasingly nervous. His strange conduct drew the attention of the local sheriff's office. On May 19, 1969, a team of federal agents and local deputies converged on the farm where he worked. They found Tingler in a field and, after disarming him of a pistol, took him into custody without a fight.

Richard Lee Tingler Jr. was extradited to Ohio to stand trial for the six murders. He was convicted in 1969 and sentenced to death. However, his sentence was commuted to life in prison in 1972 when the U.S. Supreme Court temporarily ruled against capital punishment. The case of the Rockefeller Park murders was officially closed, bringing a legal end to the brutal crime spree that had taken the lives of Joseph Zoldman and five other innocent people.

Links to Additional Sources (1)

See any mistakes? Let us know!